Show Notes

How do you actually know if your coaching is working?

In this episode of The Coaching Clinic, Angie and John unpack one of the most uncomfortable—and most important—questions for coaches: are you effective, or are you just being liked?

They challenge the common reliance on client satisfaction, renewals, and “good sessions,” and explore why those signals can be misleading. Early-stage coaches often ride the highs and lows of recent sessions, but without clear metrics, improvement becomes guesswork.

The conversation moves beyond theory into practical application—how to introduce simple, usable feedback systems without damaging trust or turning sessions into surveys. They explore the role of structured feedback (like a 0–10 rating), better questioning, and the importance of creating space for honest input.

The core message is clear: if you’re not measuring your coaching, you’re relying on assumptions—and that has consequences for your growth and your clients’ results.

This episode is a direct, honest look at how to move from “I think I’m doing a good job” to actually knowing.

Key Topics

• Why client satisfaction isn’t the same as coaching effectiveness
• The danger of recency bias in evaluating your coaching
• Why renewals and retention are incomplete metrics
• How to introduce simple feedback systems into your coaching
• Using a 0–10 rating scale effectively
• Asking better questions to get honest client feedback
• The balance between trust, challenge, and evaluation
• Why avoiding feedback limits your growth

Key Takeaway

If you’re not actively measuring your coaching, you’re guessing—and guessing limits both your development and your clients’ outcomes.

CHAPTERS

00:00 - Introduction and Topic Overview

00:41 - Measuring Coaching Effectiveness

03:18 - Personal Experiences and Insights

06:34 - The Role of Metrics in Coaching

12:11 - Feedback and Continuous Improvement

21:19 - Final thoughts on coaching and metrics.

FAQsHow do you know if your coaching is effective?

You know your coaching is effective when you move beyond gut feel and start measuring client outcomes and experience. This includes structured feedback (like session ratings), evidence of progress, and whether the client is achieving meaningful results—not just enjoying the conversation.

What are the best metrics for measuring coaching effectiveness?

There isn’t a single perfect metric, but useful ones include:

• Session ratings (e.g. 0–10 scale)
• Client progress toward goals
• Quality of client insights and actions
• Retention or re-engagement (with context)
• The key is combining quantitative feedback with qualitative insight.

Is client satisfaction a reliable way to measure coaching success?

Not on its own. Clients can enjoy sessions and still not make progress. Satisfaction reflects experience, not necessarily effectiveness. Strong coaching should challenge clients, which doesn’t always feel comfortable in the moment.

Should coaches ask for feedback after every session?

It depends on your style and structure. Some coaches use quick ratings after each session, while others gather feedback periodically. The important thing is consistency and making it easy for clients to respond honestly.

What is a simple way to measure coaching sessions?

A practical method is using a 0–10 rating at the end of a session, followed by one or two focused questions like:

• What made it that score?
• What would have made it higher?
• This keeps feedback simple but actionable.

Why do coaches avoid asking for honest feedback?

Because it’s uncomfortable. Honest feedback can challenge your confidence and expose blind spots. But avoiding it limits growth and can lead to losing clients without understanding why.

How can you ask for feedback without damaging the coaching relationship?

Frame feedback as part of the process, not a critique. Make it clear that:

• It helps you serve them better
• There are no negative consequences
• You’re looking for improvement, not validation
• Psychological safety is key.

Are client renewals a good measure of coaching success?

They’re useful but incomplete. A client staying on doesn’t always mean they’re getting results—it may reflect comfort, habit, or relationship. Renewals should be considered alongside progress and impact.

What is the biggest mistake coaches make when evaluating their performance?

Relying on intuition or recent sessions (recency bias). Many coaches judge their ability based on how the last session felt, rather than consistent patterns or structured feedback.

Can coaching be measured if it’s subjective?

Yes—but not perfectly. Coaching is subjective, but that doesn’t mean it’s unmeasurable. The goal isn’t precision, it’s clarity. Even simple metrics create better awareness than guesswork.

Why is measuring coaching important for business growth?

Without measurement, you can’t improve or identify issues early. This leads to:

• Stagnation in your coaching skills
• Lost clients without clear reasons
• Reduced referrals and growth
• Measurement turns coaching into a developable skill, not just a perceived one.

What’s the risk of not measuring your coaching?

You rely on assumptions instead of evidence. Over time, this can lead to declining results, client drop-off, and limited professional growth—often without realising why.

Want to contact the show? You can leave us a voicemail. It's free to do, and we might feature you on our next episode. All you need to do is go to https://speakpipe.com/thecoachingclinicpodcast and leave us a message. You can also find our clips and full episodes on the exclusive Coaching Clinic YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@coachingclinicpodcast

You can send us a video or voice message on LinkedIn:

John's LinkedIn Profile or go to PresentInfluence.com for coaching enquiries with John

Angie's LinkedIn Profile or visit AngieSpeaks.com

2023 Present Influence Productions Coaching Clinic: scale your business, acquire high ticket clients & master coaching skills 93