Trick or Treat, Cuties! While we're sorry to play a trick on you by re-releasing an old episode today, we're thrilled to give you the treat of TWENTY SEVEN (that's 27! Count em') minutes of bonus content ONLY EVER HEARD BEFORE ON PATREON!

Deputy Editor of US Weekly and host of “Here For the Right Reasons” podcast, Sarah Hearon, joins Donny and Chelsea to recap ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer,’ and the duo may have done research to pronounce her last name correctly, but they still don’t know a damn thing about the movie they’re covering. The three praise the Scholastic Book Fair, IMDB, and Kevin Bacon’s “The Following.” Also, they dig into horrifying childhood trauma and Donny is forced to send a HR form to Sarah when Chelsea reveals her opinions on Sarah Michelle Gellar. Then, the three discuss which of the cast is the closest to a can of beans. (This episode originally aired October 16, 2022.)

For bonus episodes and unedited & unhinged audio and video recaps, subscribe to our Patreon!

If today's episode makes you laugh (or scream), please do us a favor and rate our show 5 STARS on Apple or Spotify

Follow Us on Social Media!

TikTok: @cuteonepodcast

Chelsea: @ohnochels

Donny: @realdonnywood

Support the show

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices