13 year old, Kelly Ann Tinyes, walked down the street to her neighbor’s house in Valley Stream, New York. The young girl was never seen alive again. When police found her body, they could have never prepared themselves for what they were about to witness. The trial was filled with outbursts of emotion from the gallery, while the defendant kept his head down most of the time. A juror who sat on the trial shared insight with me, and also spoke about how the months-long trial affected her. This brutal murder would pit two families against each other ….for decades.

MURDERISH now has a Patreon page. If you’d like to support Murderish, and get extra perks in exchange, click here: www.patreon.com/murderish. 

Follow MURDERISH on social media:

Facebook: Murderish Podcast https://www.facebook.com/groups/540494462961219/     

Twitter: @MurderishPod https://twitter.com/MurderishPod

Instagram: @MurderishPodcast

Send comments and advertising inquiries to: [email protected]

MURDERISH merch now available (t-shirts, mugs & other swag): Murderish | Threadless online merch store https://murderishpodcast.threadless.com/

Midroll Podcast Promo: Crimes of Passion. Hit SUBSCRIBE in your favorite podcast app! 

Postroll Podcast Promo: Dark Poutine podcast. Hit SUBSCRIBE in your favorite podcast app!

This episode was researched & written by: Kennedy Caldwell | MURDERISH Researcher.

This episode was Edited, Mixed and Mastered by John Bukenas of Audio Editing Solutions www.audioeditingsolutions.com. Need a great audio editor? John B. is your guy!

Music in this episode created by: Nico Vettese of We Talk of Dreams. Contact Nico at [email protected] or www.wetalkofdreams.com if you’re interested in working with him to create music for your podcast …or any project!

Remember, listening to this podcast doesn’t make you a murderer …it just means you’re MURDER…ISH!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices