Midrats

Does the US Navy have the right number and mix of amphibious ships, and are those ships being properly maintained?

The Government Accountability Office’s (GAO) recent report to Congress explored this topic in depth, and today’s Midrats Podcast will delve into it further.

From the summary of the report:
Amphibious warfare ships are critical for Marine Corps missions, but the Navy has struggled to ensure they are available for operations and training. In some cases, ships in the amphibious fleet have not been available for years at a time. The Navy and Marine Corps are working to agree on a ship availability goal but have yet to complete a metrics-based analysis to support such a goal. Until the Navy completes this analysis, it risks jeopardizing its ability to align amphibious ship schedules with the Marine Corps units that deploy on them.

As of March 2024, half of the amphibious fleet is in poor condition and these ships are not on track to meet their expected service lives.

Our guests for the full hour to discuss the report and its implications will be two joint directors for the project, Shelby S. Oakley, Director, Contracting and National Security Acquisitions, and Diana Maurer Director, Defense Capabilities and Management at GAO.

Showlinks

• GAO Report: AMPHIBIOUS WARFARE FLEET Navy Needs to Complete Key Efforts to Better Ensure Ships Are Available for Marines
• GAO Report: Navy Readiness: Actions Needed to Improve Support for Sailor-Led Maintenance

Summary

The conversation delves into the critical state of the U.S. Navy's amphibious fleet, focusing on the challenges of ship maintenance, the role of the Government Accountability Office (GAO) in assessing fleet readiness, and the ongoing controversy between the Navy and Marine Corps regarding ship availability. The discussion highlights the importance of metrics, accountability, and transparency in addressing these issues, as well as the need for a cultural shift within the Navy to prioritize maintenance and resource allocation effectively.

Takeaways

• Metrics and definitions of ship readiness need to be standardized.
• Cultural and bureaucratic challenges hinder effective maintenance practices.
• Accountability is essential for improving the Navy's operational readiness.
• Budgeting for maintenance is often deprioritized in favor of new acquisitions.
• Sailors are overworked and under-resourced, impacting their performance.
• The Navy must address root causes of maintenance issues to improve fleet readiness.
• Future leadership changes present an opportunity for reform in the Navy.

Chapters

00:00: Introduction and Context of the Discussion
02:03: Understanding the GAO's Role in National Security
09:35: Insights from the Fleet: Realities of Ship Maintenance
14:49: Defining Ship Availability and Readiness
18:15: The Need for Metrics and Accountability
22:22: Challenges in Navy Bureaucracy and Culture
30:04: Navigating Accountability in Navy Maintenance
33:02: The Consequences of Deferred Maintenance
36:53: Policy Challenges in Navy Maintenance
43:09: Budgeting for Maintenance vs. New Acquisitions
45:53: Cultural Attitudes Towards Manpower and Maintenance
49:15: Realistic Expectations in Maintenance Planning
54:34: Future Directions for Navy Reports and Accountability

Full Guest Bios

Ms. Oakley is a Director in the Government Accountability Office’s (GAO) Contracting and National Security Acquisitions team. In her role, she oversees GAO’s portfolio of work examining the most complex and expensive acquisitions within the federal government. Her portfolio includes Navy and Coast Guard Shipbuilding programs, DOD acquisition policy and oversight, and leading practices in product development. In addition, she is responsible for GAO’s annual work to assess the cost, schedule, and performance of DOD’s entire portfolio of major defense and middle-tier acquisition programs. Ms. Oakley previously served as a Director in GAO’s Natural Resources and Environment team where she led teams reviewing a range of nuclear security, policy, and nonproliferation related issues. From 2004 to 2015, Ms. Oakley led teams reviewing the activities of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) with a focus on helping NASA improve its acquisition management practices. Her reviews covered key aspects of NASA’s operations, such as Space Shuttle workforce transition and sustainment of the International Space Station, as well as reviews of all major NASA systems including in-depth reviews of NASA’s human spaceflight programs and the James Webb Space Telescope. Ms. Oakley earned a Master’s Degree in Public Administration from the University of Pittsburgh’s Graduate School of Public and International Affairs and her Bachelor of Arts Degree from Washington and Jefferson College.

Ms. Maurer is a Director in the U.S. Government Accountability Office’s (GAO) Defense Capabilities and Management team, where she currently leads GAO’s independent oversight of sustainment and readiness across the military services and the Office of the Secretary of Defense. Her recent work includes reviews of F-35 sustainment, Air Force and Army force generation, Navy ship maintenance, missile defense sustainment, Space Force readiness, and the mission capability of military aviation and surface ships. She has testified three dozen times before Congressional committees on a variety of issues including the F-35, military readiness, Navy ship maintenance, national drug control policy, and several DHS and DOJ management issues.Ms. Maurer was a Director in GAO’s Homeland Security and Justice team from 2009-2017, where she led GAO’s oversight of the federal prison system; the Secret Service, FBI and other federal law enforcement agencies; and DHS’s efforts to build a unified department. She worked from 2008-2009 as an Acting Director in GAO’s Natural Resource and Environment team. From 1993-2007, Ms. Maurer worked in GAO’s International team, where she led reviews of a variety of international security issues including efforts to combat the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. Ms. Maurer began her GAO career in 1990 in GAO’s Detroit Regional Office.

Ms. Maurer has an M.S. in national resource strategy from the National Defense University where she was recognized as a Distinguished Graduate of the Industrial College of the Armed Forces. Ms. Maurer also has an M.P.P in international public policy from the University of Michigan and a B.A. in international relations from Michigan State University.

When a report has an opening like this, you know you have to find a way to get the author on Midrats.

As a nation, we are in an undeclared state of emergency.…This is a hot Cold War II. The West has empirically lost deterrence. We must respond to this emergency to regain it.
We have a peer adversary: China. “Near-Peer” is a shibboleth, a euphemism to avoid the embarrassment of acknowledging we have peers when we were once peerless.

That quote is from The Defense Reformation, written last October by Shyam Sankar the Chief Technology Officer for Palantir.

So many of the issues my cohost and I have been covering on Midrats the last decade and a half; personnel reform, Goldwater-Nichols, COCOM reform, the accretion encumbered acquisition program, and more are not just addressed in Sankar’s 18 Thesis, as I outlined in my Substack on it a few months ago, he provides solutions and new approaches.

Get a fresh cup of coffee, relax, and enjoy an impactful hour of conversation for those interested in reforming the US military towards a stronger, more responsive steward of our nation’s defense.

Summary

In this conversation, Sal, Mark, and Shyam Sankar discuss the need for innovation within the Department of Defense. They explore historical parallels, the importance of creativity, and the role a Silicon Valley mindset can have in national security. The discussion emphasizes the need for agility in budgeting, the impact of monopsony on procurement, and the significance of software in modern warfare. They also highlight the importance of founders and innovative thinking in driving change within the defense sector.

Takeaways

• The historical context of the Reformation can inform modern defense strategies.
• Creativity and innovation are essential for overcoming bureaucratic structures in defense.
• Silicon Valley's involvement in defense technology is crucial for national security.
• Lessons from the automotive industry can be applied to improve defense procurement.
• Founders play a vital role in driving innovation and change in organizations.
• People, processes, and policies must be aligned to optimize defense operations.
• Monopsony in defense procurement limits competition and innovation.
• Agility in budgeting is necessary to respond to changing defense needs.
• Stockpiles are less important than the ability to produce weapons quickly.
• Software is a key component in achieving asymmetric advantages in warfare.

Chapters

00:00: Introduction to Defense Reformation
03:21: Historical Context: The Reformation and Defense Reform
06:18: Creativity and Innovation in Defense
09:04: The Role of Silicon Valley in National Security
11:42: The Legacy of McNamara and Defense Management
14:30: Protecting Innovative Personalities in Defense
17:14: The Need for Modernization in Defense Policies
20:05: Monopsony in Defense Procurement
22:59: Encouraging Founders and Innovation in Defense
32:36: The Nature of Venture Capital and Innovation
33:08: Learning from Failure: The SpaceX Approach
34:21: Breaking Down Bureaucracy: The Need for Reinvention
36:24: Institutionalizing Rebellion: Encouraging Innovation
38:46: Leveraging Free Market Principles in Military Operations
41:06: The Role of Combatant Commanders in Defense Budgeting
43:09: Reassessing Cost-Plus Contracting in Defense
46:23: The Need for Agility in Budget Processes
49:11: The Importance of Production Over Stockpiles
52:58: Empowering Decision-Making in Military Leadership
57:41: Harnessing Software as a National Superpower

There is almost a cottage industry in appreciating the decades-long shortfall in America’s maritime industrial base for shipbuilding and repair.After more than a decade of self-delusion in labeling the People’s Republic of China (PRC) as merely a ‘Pacing Challenge’, people are increasingly waking up to the fact that the PRC has overtaken the USA in the maritime arena—a domain in which we were globally unchallenged since the end of WWII.

When considering both its vast commercial capacity and its development of the world’s largest navy, it is a fair argument to make that the maritime challenge posed by the PRC now eclipses the threat posed by the Soviet Union at its peak.

With time being short, are there solutions? There are, as outlined by our guests for today’s Midrats, Michael Roberts & Bryan Clark and their report Shoring Up the Foundation: Affordable Approaches to Improve US and Allied Shipbuilding and Ship Repair from The Hudson Institute.

Mike Roberts joined the Hudson Institute beginning in 2022. Before then Mike was the general counsel and a senior leader with Crowley Maritime, a top American shipping company, and president of the American Maritime Partnership. His focus is on commercial shipping and shipbuilding industries, and specifically, how fundamental changes in US maritime policies are needed to compete with China.

Bryan Clark is a senior fellow and director of the Center for Defense Concepts and Technology at Hudson Institute. He studies naval operations, cyber and electromagnetic warfare, autonomous systems, military competitions, and wargaming. He is a retired enlisted and officer submariner and his last job in the Navy was as Commander’s Action Group Director for the CNO.

Summary

This conversation delves into the pressing challenges facing the U.S. maritime industry, particularly the shipbuilding sector, in light of China's overwhelming shipbuilding capacity. The discussion highlights the need for affordable solutions, legislative support, and workforce development to revitalize the U.S. maritime industrial base. The guests, Mike Roberts and Bryan Clark, present their report from the Hudson Institute, which outlines actionable policies to enhance U.S. and allied shipping and ship repair capabilities. They emphasize the importance of a consistent demand signal from the government to stabilize the industry and attract skilled workers. The conversation delves into the challenges faced by the US Navy in maintaining maritime readiness and resilience in the face of potential conflicts, particularly with China. It discusses the need for a robust US-flagged shipping fleet, the implications of supply chain vulnerabilities, and the importance of leveraging allied shipbuilding capacities. The speakers emphasize the necessity of innovative shipbuilding strategies, improved maintenance practices, and a shift in mindset to prepare for future military operations effectively.

Takeaways

• The U.S. maritime industrial base faces significant challenges.
• China's shipbuilding capacity far exceeds that of the U.S.
• Affordable solutions are necessary for immediate impact.
• Legislative support is crucial for revitalizing shipbuilding.
• Workforce development is essential for the shipbuilding industry.
• The Ships for America Act aims to increase U.S. flag fleet.
• Educational benefits can attract skilled workers to shipyards.
• A consistent demand signal is vital for industry stability.
• Shipbuilding is a low-margin business requiring government support.
• Investment in workforce training is critical for future success. The US needs a sufficient number of ships to support major combat operations overseas.
• China's control over global shipping assets poses a significant risk to US supply chains.
• The US Navy's reliance on foreign-flagged ships may not be viable in wartime.
• Innovative shipbuilding practices, including AI, can enhance Navy capabilities.
• Improving ship repair readiness is crucial for fleet capacity by 2027.
• The Navy must adapt its technical standards to facilitate faster shipbuilding.
• Allied shipbuilding capacities can be leveraged to enhance US naval strength.
• A consistent demand signal is necessary for ship repair yards to thrive.
• The Navy's public shipyards require significant infrastructure upgrades.
• A cultural shift within the Navy is essential to address current challenges.

Sound Bites

• "China has 230 times the amount of shipbuilding capacity."
• "The Navy is far from its readiness goals."
• "We need to build capacity not just for peace but for war."
• "We can build uncrewed vessels in many different places."
• "We have to change the mindset we've been living with."

Chapters

00:00: Introduction to Maritime Challenges
03:11: The Shipbuilding Capacity Gap
06:04: Affordable Solutions for Shipbuilding
15:05: Legislative Support: Ships for America Act
17:29: Workforce Development in Shipbuilding
29:24: Long-term Stability in Shipbuilding Industry
34:10: Navigating Maritime Challenges and Supply Chain Resilience
41:07: Innovations in Shipbuilding and Maintenance Strategies
50:31: Leveraging Allied Shipbuilding and Repair Capacities
57:59: Preparing for Future Conflicts and Fleet Readiness

Happy New Year to everyone…and Midrats is back with you.

Join us today for a broad-ranging discussion for our 15th Anniversary Show with a regular guest since the start, Claude Berube.

The conversation will go who knows where, but we will begin by reflecting on how the defense media and information environment has evolved since 2010—not just from the perspective of the information consumer, but also in terms of where decision-makers turn for opinions and ideas. We’ll include some inside baseball as well, starting with how the relationship between the PAO world and the broader number and flavor of media has evolved.

Here’s to the 16th Season!

Claude Berube, PhD, is a retired Navy Commander and retired professor from the Naval Academy. He's worked on Capitol Hill and as a contractor for Naval Sea Systems Command and the Office of Naval Research. He also worked at the Office of Naval Intelligence. He is the author or co-author of eight books including his most recent. He is working on his ninth book, about the Navy and the lead up to World War 2. His new podcast about the United States Senate will begin later this month.

Showlinks

• Powerline Blog and Dan Rather’s Memogate
• MWI’s “Spear” podcast
• The Failure of the Institutions
• Claude’s “Siren’s Song” and other books
• War on the Rocks
• CIMSEC
• Bill Roggio & Long War Journal
• Sal Mergcogliano’s What’s Going on With Shipping
• John Konrad’s gCaptain
• Geopolitics Decanted Podcast
• Information Dissemination blog, by Raymond Pritchett

Summary

In this episode of the MidRats podcast, hosts Sal and Mark celebrate the 15th anniversary of their show with guest Claude Berube. They discuss the evolution of information in national security, the impact of media on public perception, and the changing landscape of military communication. The conversation highlights the importance of accountability, transparency, and credible voices in media, as well as the collaborative nature of modern information sharing. They also look ahead to future projects and initiatives in the realm of military and national security communication.

Takeaways

• The Midrats podcast has been a consistent platform for naval discussions for 15 years.
• The evolution of information access has transformed national security discourse.
• Public Affairs Officers have become more cautious in their engagement with the media.
• The military's communication strategies have shifted significantly over the years.
• Accountability and transparency are essential for maintaining public trust in the military.
• A culture of untruth can undermine the credibility of official statements.
• Independent media sources are increasingly important for accurate information.
• Collaboration among information producers enhances the quality of discourse.
• Future initiatives in military communication will focus on transparency and engagement.

Sound Bites

• "It's amazing how fast time flies."
• "This is the C-SPAN for the Navy."
• "The future is disaggregated."

Chapters

00:00: Celebrating 15 Years of Midrats Podcast
02:16: The Evolution of Naval Information
06:28: Democratization of Media and Its Impacts
14:54: The Changing Role of Public Affairs in the Navy
27:11: Navigating a Culture of Untruth in Media
32:48: Independence in Media: The Value of Non-Sponsorship
35:31: The Role of Personalities in Information Dissemination
37:59: The Importance of Open Dialogue and Accountability
42:01: Self-Correction in New Media
44:48: The Credibility of Online Sources
47:40: The Future of Media and Influence
55:25: Upcoming Projects and Future Endeavors

With one of the most militarily and energy strategic states in our union, Alaska, being in the Arctic, and the extensive interests we have on the other side of the planet in Antarctica, do you wonder why our nation’s icebreaking “fleet”—being what it is—amounts to an antique road show? Are you curious how our plan to replace them is making the LCS program look like a successful and well-run program? Can a nation of 335 million souls learn something from a nation of 5.5 million?

Today’s Midrats is for you with our guest, Peter Rybski.

Pete is a retired nuclear-trained surface warfare officer who has served on six different ships and a couple of overseas staffs. His last job on Active Duty was as the U.S. Naval Attache to Finland. It was in that position that he began a deep dive into icebreakers and icebreaking technology. Pete retired in 2021, but remained in Finland, where he and his family live 106 miles from the Russian border.Forgot the most important part- He writes about icebreakers, security policy, and general life in Finland over at his Substack, Sixty Degrees North.

Showlinks

• Sixty Degrees North article on USCG Polar Security Cutter Program
• Sea ice tracker
• USCGC Healy (WAGB-20)
• gCaptain article on Chinese icebreakers
• Polar Security Cutter Program from Wikipedia
• Wind Class icebreakers
• Icebreaker Collaboration Effort (ICE)
• Sam LaGrone article on the VT Halter icebreaker program
• Le Commandant Charcot, French icebreaking cruise ship
• Finland icebreaking Missile Corvettes
• Aker Arctic
• Dr Elizabeth Buchanan on X

Summary

This conversation delves into the critical role of icebreakers in U.S. Arctic strategy, highlighting the challenges faced by the U.S. Coast Guard in maintaining and expanding its icebreaker fleet. Guest Peter Rybski shares his experiences in Finland, where he developed a keen interest in icebreakers, and discusses the historical context of U.S. icebreaker capabilities compared to other nations. The dialogue also addresses procurement issues, legal challenges, and the necessity for armed icebreakers in the Arctic, culminating in a discussion about international cooperation through the Icebreaker Coalition.

Takeaways

• The U.S. has not built an icebreaker in 50 years.
• 80% of the world's icebreakers are designed in Finland.
• The Coast Guard has been slow to prioritize icebreaker needs.
• China is rapidly expanding its icebreaker fleet.
• The procurement process for U.S. icebreakers is dysfunctional.
• International cooperation is essential for icebreaker capabilities.
• The U.S. needs to consider purchasing foreign-built icebreakers.
• Armed icebreakers are necessary for Arctic security.
• The Icebreaker Coalition aims to enhance collaboration among allies.
• Political will is crucial for advancing U.S. icebreaker strategy.

Chapters

• 00:00: Introduction to Icebreakers and Arctic Strategy
• 06:10: Transitioning to Finland: A Personal Journey
• 13:03: The Importance of Icebreakers in Global Trade
• 18:12: Challenges in U.S. Icebreaker Procurement
• 24:34: The Complexity of Icebreaker Design and Construction
• 30:00: Understanding the Delays in Icebreaker Development
• 31:15: Legal and Political Constraints in Shipbuilding
• 34:34: The Need for a Comprehensive Icebreaker Strategy
• 37:17: Arming Icebreakers: A Strategic Discussion
• 43:52: The Icebreaker Coalition: Collaboration and Challenges
• 47:19: Finland's Defense Purchases and U.S. Relations
• 51:42: China's Growing Influence in Antarctica
• 53:53: Future Insights and Closing Thoughts

Trying to get your mind around who the actors are in Syria as this 'frozen conflict' from the last decade begins to thaw?If you are concerned about international jihadist organizations, the security of Israel, instability caused by mass migration, rights of religious minorities in the Middle East, or human suffering, the cascading events in Syria should be in your scan.


Well, this Midrats is just for you. Returning to Midrats for the full hour to give an overview of the different players in the conflict, from the perspective of a US Marine who helped lead the fight in an earlier phase of this long conflict, will be Seth W.B. Folsom.

Seth is a retired Marine Corps colonel who served more than twenty-eight years in uniform. Throughout the Global War on Terror, he deployed multiple times to Iraq and Afghanistan, where he commanded in combat at the company, battalion, and task force levels. A graduate of the University of Virginia, Naval Postgraduate School, and the Marine Corps War College, he also is the author of “The Highway War: A Marine Company Commander in Iraq;” “In the Gray Area: A Marine Advisor Team at War;” “Where Youth and Laughter Go: With ‘the Cutting Edge’ in Afghanistan;” and the forthcoming “Nothing Here Worth Dying For: Task Force Lion in Iraq.”

He lives with his family and their needy cat in Southern California.You can listen here or at the Spotify widget below:

Showlinks

• Nothing Here Worth Dying For: Task Force Lion in Iraq, by Seth Folsom
• Hardcore History Series, Dan Carlin

Summary

In this conversation, Sal, Mark, and Seth discuss the complexities of the Syrian conflict, drawing connections to historical events and the role of various actors involved. They explore the implications of the recent developments in Syria, including the potential for humanitarian crises and the influence of external forces. The discussion also touches on military strategies, the significance of ethnic and religious groups, and the challenges faced by the international community in addressing the situation.

Takeaways

• The Syrian conflict is deeply intertwined with historical and regional complexities.
• Jihadist groups in Syria present a complicated landscape that defies simple categorization.
• Comparisons to past conflicts, such as the Afghan Civil War, highlight potential future challenges in Syria.
• Ethnic and religious divisions in Syria complicate the political landscape and future governance.
• External actors, including Turkey and Iran, play significant roles in shaping the conflict's outcome.
• Humanitarian concerns are paramount as the situation in Syria evolves.
• The international community's response to the crisis will be critical in determining future stability.

Chapters

00:00: Introduction to the Syrian Conflict
03:00: Task Force Lion and Its Role in Iraq and Syria
11:09: The Complexity of Syrian Factions
13:48: Comparisons to Historical Conflicts
19:49: The Future of Syria and Regional Implications
30:43: Historical Context and Military Logistics
36:20: The Evolving Threat of ISIS
38:03: Geopolitical Dynamics in the Middle East
44:27: Humanitarian Crisis and International Response
52:34: Reflections on Military Experience and Future Implications

Before everyone dives into a week of family and fasting, time to catch up with Sal and Mark on Midrats.From the retention crisis to some stark comments from senior leaders about the Western Pacific, we’ll cover the waterfront and more.

Showlinks

• Fighter pilot burnout
• Admiral Paparo at Brookings
• Dereliction of Duty: Johnson, McNamara, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Lies That Led to Vietnam

Summary

In this episode, Sal and Mark discuss the complexities of national defense, focusing on the importance of personnel in the military, the challenges of recruitment and retention, and the impact of deployment lengths on service members' lives. They explore the zero-sum nature of military personnel management, the strategic decisions that need to be made regarding deployments, and the role of allies in global military dynamics. The conversation critiques current military strategies and reflects on the future of military engagements, emphasizing the need for a reevaluation of military policy and priorities. In this conversation, Sal and Mark discuss the economic vulnerabilities of nations, particularly focusing on the UK's reliance on maritime access and the implications for military readiness. They explore the challenges of budgetary pressures on defense spending, the inefficiencies within government bureaucracy, and the need for a reevaluation of military strategy in light of current geopolitical realities. The discussion emphasizes the importance of joint operations and the necessity for a more efficient allocation of resources to ensure national security.

Chapters

00:00: Introduction and Thanksgiving Greetings
03:02: The People Behind National Defense
06:10: Challenges in Retention and Recruitment
08:54: The Zero-Sum Game of Military Personnel
11:49: The Impact of Deployment Length on Retention
15:08: Strategic Decisions in Military Deployments
17:51: The Role of Allies and Global Military Dynamics
21:01: Critique of Current Military Strategies
23:58: The Complexity of International Conflicts
27:12: The Future of Military Engagements
29:56: Conclusion and Reflections on Military Policy
32:15: The Economic Vulnerability of Nations
35:52: Military Readiness and Strategic Realities
39:42: Budgetary Pressures and Social Welfare Challenges
43:17: Government Efficiency and Bureaucratic Challenges
49:10: Rethinking Military Strategy and Deterrence
57:11: The Future of Military Operations and Joint Forces

With 63 days until President Trump’s second inauguration and a new national security team lining up, what are the expected opportunities they will be looking to make an impact quickly? What should people be looking at? Where is the fruit ripe for the picking?

For the full hour we have returning guest, Jerry Dunleavy IV, author of Kabul: The Untold Story of Biden’s Fiasco and the American Warriors Who Fought to the End, Former investigative journalist for the Washington Examiner, & former senior investigator for the House Foreign Affairs Committee. 

Summary:
In this conversation, Jerry Dunleavy discusses the implications of Trump's presidency, focusing on the shock experienced in Washington during his election and the subsequent challenges faced by the administration. He emphasizes the need for accountability regarding the Afghanistan situation and the potential pushback from entrenched bureaucracies. The conversation also touches on Trump's agenda for government reform and the overlooked threats posed by COVID and fentanyl, highlighting the intelligence community's lack of interest in these issues. The discussion concludes with reflections on the topics covered.

Chapters:
00:00: Introduction
02:22: Accountability in the Trump Administration
08:47: Lawfare and Political Resistance
09:09: Consequences of Intelligence Failures
09:34: The Hunter Biden Laptop Controversy
11:51: Politicization of Intelligence
14:01: Accountability in Intelligence and Military
19:54: Challenges in Military Leadership
28:43: National Security Challenges Ahead
33:49: Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in the Military
44:43: China's Influence and Accountability
55:49: Future Directions and Closing Thoughts

Summary

The conversation delves into various themes surrounding innovation, customization, and future planning. It highlights the importance of bespoke solutions in development and addresses the challenges faced in implementing these ideas. The speakers reflect on their insights and look forward to new developments in the field.Show Links

• Trump Declares No Mercy on Cartels
• Chris Cappy from Task & Purpose on the Cartel Wars
• Red Hill Fuel Storage Report
• Who Put Quartermaster Bloomfield in Charge of Defending Guam?
• Elbridge Colby on Tucker Carlson’s Show
• Elbridge Colby on Midrats
• Return to Tinian
• Building Navy Bases in WWII
• The Art of Military Innovation: Lessons from the Israel Defense Forces, by Edward N. Luttwak

Chapters

00:00: Introduction and Veterans Day Reflection02:55: Post-Election Analysis and Military Implications
09:05: National Security and Fuel Storage Concerns
13:54: War on Cartels: A New Approach
18:35: Military Cooperation with Mexico
23:33: Political Polarization and Bureaucratic Challenges
27:08: International Relations and Energy Policies
29:14: Political Landscape and Defense Spending
32:52: Innovations in Military Technology
35:36: Strategic Military Planning and Leadership
38:17: Naval Strategy and Regional Security
40:58: Impact of Political Changes on Foreign Policy
44:25: Military Readiness and Resource Allocation
49:14: Bureaucratic Challenges in Defense5
4:43: Critique of Diversity Initiatives in the Military

Showlinks

• Joint Sword 2024 off Taiwan.
• TAFFY-3 off Samar.
• USAF NGAD Pause.
• Narrow Seas, Small Navies, and Fat Merchantmen: Naval Strategies for the 1990s.
• USS Carney’s 1 year anniversary.
• Debt service now greater than spending on defense.

Summary

In this episode of Midrats, Sal and Mark discuss the evolving geopolitical landscape, focusing on China's strategic maneuvers around Taiwan and the implications for US military preparedness. They explore the potential for conflict, the challenges facing the US Navy, and the need for a reevaluation of military strategy and acquisition processes. The conversation highlights the complexities of international relations and the shifting balance of power in the region. In this conversation, Mark and Sal delve into the complexities of naval strategy, fleet composition, and the lessons learned from historical engagements like Taffy 3. They discuss the limitations of wargaming, the need for modernization in naval warfare, and the challenges of military production in times of peace. The dialogue also touches on the shifting global power dynamics and the implications for military strategy, particularly in relation to Israel and the broader international community.

Takeaways

• The ongoing conflict in the Red Sea highlights the complexities of modern warfare.
• China's maneuvers around Taiwan reflect a strategic approach to territorial claims.
• The use of non-military assets by China complicates international responses.
• The US military faces significant challenges in terms of preparedness and resources.
• China's strategy may involve a slow strangulation of Taiwan's economy.
• International recognition of Taiwan's sovereignty is dwindling.
• The US's military pivot to the Pacific has not been adequately supported by resources.
• Naval strategy must adapt to the realities of modern warfare in narrow seas.
• The acquisition process for military assets is slow and risk-averse.
• There is a pressing need for change in military development and strategy. The importance of having a diverse fleet for various combat scenarios.
• Historical engagements like Taffy 3 provide valuable lessons for modern naval strategy.
• Wargaming often fails to capture the unpredictability of real-world engagements.
• Smaller, well-led units can outperform larger forces under the right conditions.
• The U.S. Navy needs to modernize its approach to warfare and fleet composition.
• Production capabilities must align with wartime needs to ensure readiness.
• Understanding global power dynamics is crucial for effective military strategy.
• The international community's perception of military actions can impact alliances.
• Decisive action is necessary when dealing with irrational adversaries.
• Military strategy must evolve to address contemporary threats effectively.

Sound Bites

• "Halloween's spooktacular, but all our shows are spooktacular."
• "We need to think about smaller, highly armed boats."
• "Wargames are limited by assumptions and math."
• "Taffy 3 turned around a massive Japanese force."

Chapters

00:00: Introduction and Context Setting
01:55: China's Strategic Maneuvers Around Taiwan
09:55: The Implications of China's Actions
18:13: US Military Preparedness and Response
26:05: Challenges in Naval Strategy and Acquisition
32:07: Future of Military Development and Change Management
33:47: Navigating Naval Strategy and Fleet Composition
39:49: Lessons from History: The Taffy 3 Engagement
45:40: The Need for Modernization in Naval Warfare
52:19: Production Challenges in Military Readiness
56:05: Understanding Global Power Dynamics and Military Strategy