Magical Overthinkers

Overthinking About Misinformation


Listen Later

We live in an era where misinformation spreads faster than ever—shaping our beliefs, fueling our anxieties, and making it nearly impossible to separate fact from fiction. Why are our brains so susceptible to false narratives even when we know better? How do we resist falling for this stuff? And also, where is the line separating misinformation from harmless ~lore~ anyway?

In this special episode, host Amanda Montell (@amanda_montell) reads an exclusive excerpt from her new book, The Age of Magical Overthinking, diving into the psychology behind misinformation, revealing some mistakes of her own, and exploring the linguistic tricks that make debunking a falsehood so much harder than believing it in the first place.

Listen to the full audiobook here: https://bit.ly/48mnRkG

Audio excerpt courtesy of Simon & Schuster Audio from THE AGE OF MAGICAL OVERTHINKING by Amanda Montell, read by the author. Copyright © 2024 by Amanda Montell. Used with permission of Simon & Schuster, Inc.

For more, follow @simon.audio on IG and @SimonAudio on FB/X!


Overthinker Corrections:

From our episode on toxins, the Environmental Working Group (EWG) has faced controversy over the years, with critics arguing that it overstates chemical risks, relies on flawed methodologies, and promotes an organic marketing agenda. Despite these concerns, EWG defends its work as being rooted in a mission to protect public health and empower consumers to make safer choices. For those seeking alternative resources to the EWG, consider exploring Consumer Reports for independent product testing and safety insights, and Made Safe for certified non-toxic product recommendations.


A couple of points made in our fertility interview—namely, the study about birth control pills disrupting pheromones and the implication that hormonal IUDs and birth control pills can cause the same side effects—are debated. Listen to Science Vs the Pill to learn more. Thanks for your listenership and thoughtful engagement! Overall, we hope this episode inspires more critical conversation and self-advocacy, and less shame, about the thought spiral-inducing subject of fertility 


- Join the "Magical Overthinkers Club" by following the pod on Instagram @magicaloverthinkers.

- To access early, ad-free episodes and more, subscribe to the Magical Overthinkers Substack.

- Pick up a hard copy of Amanda's book The Age of Magical Overthinking: Notes on Modern Irrationality, or listen to the audiobook.


Thanks to Our Sponsors:

  • No matter how you say it, don’t overpay for it. Shop plans at https://MINTMOBILE.com/magical
  • Stop putting off those doctors appointments and go to https://Zocdoc.com/MAGICAL to find and instantly book a top-rated doctor today
  • Check out the Fits Everybody Collection at https://www.skims.com/magical #skimspartner
  • Cannot use any other commissionable clothing links including, but not limited to, LTK, MagicLinks, Amazon Storefront, ShopMy, etc.
  • Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    Magical OverthinkersBy Amanda Montell & Studio71

    • 4.4
    • 4.4
    • 4.4
    • 4.4
    • 4.4

    4.4

    546 ratings


    More shows like Magical Overthinkers

    View all
    This American Life by This American Life

    This American Life

    90,778 Listeners

    Death, Sex & Money by Slate Podcasts

    Death, Sex & Money

    7,735 Listeners

    Decoder Ring by Slate Podcasts

    Decoder Ring

    2,063 Listeners

    You're Wrong About by Sarah Marshall

    You're Wrong About

    21,596 Listeners

    American Hysteria by chelsey weber-smith

    American Hysteria

    3,159 Listeners

    Maintenance Phase by Aubrey Gordon & Michael Hobbes

    Maintenance Phase

    16,079 Listeners

    Sounds Like A Cult by Studio71

    Sounds Like A Cult

    3,842 Listeners

    Normal Gossip by Normal Gossip

    Normal Gossip

    5,555 Listeners

    Petty Crimes by Hartbeat

    Petty Crimes

    705 Listeners

    If Books Could Kill by Michael Hobbes & Peter Shamshiri

    If Books Could Kill

    8,557 Listeners

    Something More Human by Sam & Elliot

    Something More Human

    166 Listeners

    Culture Study Podcast by Anne Helen Petersen

    Culture Study Podcast

    616 Listeners

    Finally! A Show by iHeartPodcasts

    Finally! A Show

    214 Listeners

    I'm Right You're Wrong by Isa Medina

    I'm Right You're Wrong

    251 Listeners

    Conspiracy, She Wrote by Unladylike Media

    Conspiracy, She Wrote

    162 Listeners