In 1590, Governor John White returned to Roanoke Island after a three-year absence to find an abandoned settlement, scattered possessions, and a single cryptic word carved into a tree: "CROATOAN." All 117 English colonists—including his infant granddaughter Virginia Dare, the first English child born in the Americas—had vanished without a trace.

Three years earlier, in 1587, White had left the struggling colony to return to England for desperately needed supplies. When Spanish armada conflicts delayed his return, the colonists faced starvation, hostile relations with neighboring tribes, and the isolation of being 3,000 miles from help. White's discovery of the empty fort launched America's oldest unsolved mystery—one that has captivated historians, archaeologists, and investigators for over four centuries.

What happened to the Lost Colony? Did they integrate with the Croatoan tribe? Were they killed by Spanish forces or rival Native Americans? Or did they attempt a desperate relocation that ended in tragedy? Despite centuries of theories, archaeological digs, and historical analysis, the fate of Roanoke's colonists remains one of American history's most enduring mysteries.

Subscribe to Hometown History for forgotten American history stories every week. New episodes release Tuesdays. Every hometown has a story—what's yours?

In 1590, 117 English colonists vanished from Roanoke Island, North Carolina, leaving behind only the word "CROATOAN" carved into a post. This is the story of America's oldest unsolved mystery.

Timeline of the Lost Colony:

• July 1587: Governor John White leads 117 colonists to establish settlement on Roanoke Island
• August 18, 1587: Virginia Dare born - first English child in the New World
• August 27, 1587: White departs for England to get supplies, leaving 115 colonists
• 1588-1589: Spanish Armada conflict delays White's return voyage
• August 18, 1590: White returns to find settlement abandoned, "CROATOAN" carved on post
• 1590-present: Mystery remains unsolved despite 400+ years of investigation

Key Figures:

• Governor John White - Colony leader and artist who documented early America
• Virginia Dare - White's granddaughter, first English child born in Americas
• Chief Manteo - Croatoan tribe leader and English ally
• Ananias Dare - Virginia's father, assistant to Governor White
• Eleanor White Dare - Virginia's mother, Governor White's daughter

Theories About What Happened:

• Integration Theory: Colonists joined the Croatoan tribe (Chief Manteo's people)
• Spanish Attack: Killed by Spanish forces seeking to eliminate English presence
• Hostile Tribes: Attacked by Powhatan or other tribes
• Failed Relocation: Attempted move to Chesapeake Bay area ended in disaster
• Starvation/Disease: Died from lack of supplies during White's absence
• Assimilation: Gradually absorbed into multiple Native American communities

Archaeological Evidence:

• Earthworks discovered in 2012 suggest colonists may have split into smaller groups
• Croatoan artifacts from Hatteras Island show European trade goods from 1587-1590 period
• DNA studies of Lumbee tribe suggest possible colonial ancestry
• "Dare Stones" controversy (1937-1941) - likely elaborate hoax

What We Know for Certain:

• 117 colonists were alive when White left in August 1587
• Settlement was orderly when abandoned (not destroyed by attack)
• "CROATOAN" was carved carefully, not hastily
• Colonists removed fortifications before leaving
• No bodies or mass graves have ever been found
• White never returned to investigate the Croatoan village

Modern Location:

Roanoke Island is now part of North Carolina's Outer Banks. Fort Raleigh National Historic Site preserves the location of the Lost Colony settlement. The outdoor drama "The Lost Colony" has been performed there every summer since 1937, making it America's longest-running outdoor symphonic drama.

Sources & Further Reading:

1. "Roanoke: Solving the Mystery of the Lost Colony" by Lee Miller (2001)
2. National Park Service - Fort Raleigh National Historic Site archives
3. "The Lost Colony and Hatteras Island" by Scott Dawson (2020)
4. British Museum - John White watercolors collection
5. University of North Carolina - First Colony Foundation research
6. "Set Fair for Roanoke: Voyages and Colonies, 1584-1606" by David B. Quinn (1985)
7. North Carolina Collection, UNC-Chapel Hill - Colonial records
8. Smithsonian Magazine - "The Mystery of the Lost Colony Endures" (2020)

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/hometownhistory/exclusive-content

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy