There's nothing as horrible as being abducted and then lied to your whole life by the people who love you... except reading about it. This week, Donny and Chelsea read the tedious fan favorite "The Face On the Milk Carton" by Caroline B. Cooney and spend that time wishing someone would chloroform them and take them away so they can stop reading. Before you attack - Donny remembered loving this book as a child, but it's not the dramatic thriller you remember. Besides spending the hour saying how miserable they are, the duo also discuss out of the box child names, sick day habits, the 90s obsession of milk and missing white girls, and most importantly - the vaginal health of the Laguna Beach cast.

Head to factormeals.com/cuteone50 and use code CUTEONE50 to get 50% off!

For bonus episodes and unedited & unhinged audio and video recaps, subscribe to our Patreon!

If today's episode makes you laugh (or scream), please do us a favor and rate our show 5 STARS on Apple or Spotify

Follow Us on Social Media!

TikTok: @cuteonepodcast

Chelsea: @ohnochels

Donny: @realdonnywood

Support the show

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices