The Knowledge Matters Podcast

“The tail is wagging the dog” | Know Better, Do Better


Listen Later

When’s the last time you finished a chapter of a book and thought, “Hmmm, what was the main idea?” Competent readers don’t ask themselves this question. They’re too busy focusing on the text itself, not the component strategies that help us understand them. 

But that’s not how traditional curriculum and instructional practices work. Instead, they teach reading through a strategy-first approach that focuses on skills like making inferences and predictions, not the text itself.

In this episode, David and Meredith Liben explore what Meredith calls “the tail wagging the dog” in reading comprehension, including examples from personal experience, insights from research, and stories of how they learned to do things differently. The Libens also highlight the costs of a strategy-first approach: missed opportunities for students to engage deeply with the ideas and implications of a text, and activity prompts that ask kids to check their brains at the door as they complete inauthentic exercises. 

Two guests join the conversation:

  • Literacy expert Margaret McKeown discusses how strategy-focused instruction  is still all too common in classrooms. It’s tangible–and is doomed to fail.
  • Fifth-grade teacher Sean Morrissey shares his firsthand experience piloting two ELA curriculums - one that centers on novels and read-alouds, and one that uses book excerpts on a common theme and tests on target strategies. The differences are stark. 

Finally, the conversation turns to a habit of mind the Libens will discuss later in the season: the standards of coherence. This is a habit of mind where a reader expects they will understand a text, and if it doesn’t make sense, they go back and do the mental work needed to make meaning from what they are reading.

For more information about this episode, visit the Knowledge Matters Podcast website. The research, studies and artifacts mentioned are posted on the Knowledge Matters Campaign curriculum review tool.

Key quote: “I want kids to know what a summary is, what an inference is. But I wouldn't say, ‘Hey, kids, today we're gonna learn to do a summary.’ What I would do is: in a discussion, if a student gave a summary of a piece of text, I would say, ‘Very nice, you gave us a good summary of that, and move on.” (McKeown)

This podcast is produced by the Knowledge Matters Campaign and StandardsWork. Follow the Knowledge Matters Campaign on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook. Search #knowledgematters and join this important conversation. If you'd like to get in touch with David and Meredith, you can contact them through their website, readingdoneright.org.

Production by Tressa Versteeg. Original music and sound engineering by Aidan Shea. Narration recorded at Bamboo Recording Studios.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Knowledge Matters PodcastBy Knowledge Matters Campaign

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

149 ratings


More shows like The Knowledge Matters Podcast

View all
The Cult of Pedagogy Podcast by Jennifer Gonzalez

The Cult of Pedagogy Podcast

2,385 Listeners

Angela Watson's Truth for Teachers by Angela Watson

Angela Watson's Truth for Teachers

1,253 Listeners

10 Minute Teacher Podcast with Cool Cat Teacher by Vicki Davis

10 Minute Teacher Podcast with Cool Cat Teacher

279 Listeners

Making Math Moments That Matter by Kyle Pearce & Jon Orr

Making Math Moments That Matter

413 Listeners

Melissa & Lori Love Literacy ™ by Powered by Great Minds

Melissa & Lori Love Literacy ™

394 Listeners

The Everyday Style School by Jennifer Mackey Mary

The Everyday Style School

501 Listeners

Science of Reading: The Podcast by Amplify Education

Science of Reading: The Podcast

618 Listeners

Teaching to the TOP by Teaching on the Double

Teaching to the TOP

643 Listeners

Triple R Teaching by Anna Geiger

Triple R Teaching

190 Listeners

Progressively Incorrect by Zach Groshell

Progressively Incorrect

33 Listeners

Literacy Talks by Reading Horizons

Literacy Talks

51 Listeners

The Literacy View by Faith Borkowsky and Judy Boksner

The Literacy View

59 Listeners

Sold a Story by APM Reports

Sold a Story

7,310 Listeners

Chalk & Talk by Anna Stokke

Chalk & Talk

36 Listeners

Shanahan on Literacy by Timothy Shanahan

Shanahan on Literacy

45 Listeners