It was August 5, 2009, a day like any other for Dalia Dippolito. She got up early to go to the gym and let her husband, Mike, know that she'd pick him up a Starbucks on her way home. While she was at the gym working on her fitness, she got a call from Sgt. Ranzie, a detective with the Boynton Beach Police Department, who told her there was a situation at her home and she needed to get there right away. When Dalia arrived, she saw her house surrounded by police cars and yellow crime scene tape. Sgt. Ranzie told her that her husband had been murdered inside their condo, and Dalia fell into his arms, sobbing. However, everything about this entire scene was completely fake.

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to hellofresh.com/creepersfree and use code creepersfree for FREE breakfast for life! One breakfast item free in every box as long as subscription is active!

Sources:

20/20 - Season 42 Episode 26, Down Payment on Death

Court Junkie Episode - Dalia Dippolito and the Attempted Murder of Her Husband 

Dalia Dippolito v. State of Florida

Testy exchanges mark third day of testimony in Dippolito retrial | WPEC

Dalia Dippolito case: Alternate juror reveals how he would have voted

Dalia Dippolito retrial: Defense argues police misconduct rooted in murder-for-hire charge – Sun Sentinel

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Martin and Michele MacNeill's adult daughters, Rachel and Alexis, are convinced their father murdered their mother. They were able to get custody of their adopted younger siblings, except 16 year old Giselle, who was inexplicably shipped off to Ukraine, where she’d been adopted from.

This was an incredibly stressful time for all of them. Rachel and Alexis were terrified of their dad. He now knew they believed he’d killed their mother, and they were so afraid he’d do the same to them that they went into hiding. But Alexis was not in hiding giving up. She was in hiding plotting.

Sources:

The Stranger She Loved: A Mormon Doctor, His Beautiful Wife, and An Almost Perfect Murder by Shanna Hogan

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to hellofresh.com/creepersfree and use code creepersfree for FREE breakfast for life! One breakfast item free in every box as long as subscription is active!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

It was April 11, 2007 when 50 year old Michele MacNeill was found unconscious in her bathtub by her husband, Martin MacNeill. Martin attempted CPR while he waited for the ambulance to arrive, but she could not be saved. Tragically, less than an hour after she arrived at the hospital, Michele was pronounced dead. Days later, the Utah State medical examiner declared that Michele’s death was due to natural causes from a heart arrhythmia. It seemed like it had just been a terrible tragedy, possibly brought on by the pain medication Michele was taking due to a recent facelift surgery. But it was not at all what it seemed, and it would take the persistent efforts of investigators, lawyers, and even the MacNeill's grown children to uncover the truth of what really happened to Michele.

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/creepersfree and use code creepersfree for FREE breakfast for life! One breakfast item in every box as long as subscription is active.

Sources:

The Stranger She Loved: A Mormon Doctor, His Beautiful Wife, and An Almost Perfect Murder by Shanna Hogan

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Helen Hagnes Mintiks had it all - a wonderful husband, a fabulous life in New York City, and her dream job as a professional violinist performing at the world famous Metropolitan Opera House. On July 23, 1980, Helen was playing in the orchestra for the visiting Berlin Ballet, but after a break in the performance, Helen never returned to finish the show. Her prized possession - her violin - sat in her empty seat, while others in the orchestra wondered where she could be. When she failed to turn up by the end of the performance, no one could understand how a someone could just vanish in the middle of a performance at the Met.

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

EarnIn

Download EarnIn today in the Google play or Apple app store! When you download the EarnIn app type in Creepers under PODCAST when you sign up! It really helps the show!

Sources:

Tragic tale of top violinist who vanished mid-performance at New York's Met Opera House

Metropolitan Opera House (Lincoln Center) - Wikipedia

The Firebird - Wikipedia

QS World University Rankings for Performing Arts 2023

Mintiks v. Metropolitan Opera, 153 A.D.2d 133 | Casetext Search + Citator

Remembering Violinist Helen Hagnes, 40 Years After Her Murder at the Met

How a Real-Life 'Phantom of the Opera' Murdered a Young Violinist at the Met in 1980 | Inside Edition

Helen Karen Mintiks | Find A Grave

New York Homicide S1 E2: Murder at the Met | Peacock

Craig Crimmins | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers

Murder at the Met: Craig Crimmins on Trial for Murder of Violinist | Archives & Special Collections | New York Times

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

On the night of January 8, 1993, two armed assailants entered a Brown's Chicken restaurant in Palatine, Illinois, just before closing time and proceeded to brutally murder seven employees, all for less than $2000. Years would go by before police would get their big break. In those interim years, the BGA would release their scathing report on the investigation, the ISCC would form their panel to refute the BGA, the victim’s families would file lawsuits against Brown’s Chicken. Everyone wanted someone to blame for this crime, but the killers remained elusive. That is, until 2002, when a phone call between old high school friends would change everything. 

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

EarnIn

Download EarnIn today in the Google play or Apple app store! When you download the EarnIn app type in Creepers under PODCAST when you sign up! It really helps the show!

Sources

Book: 

Shocking Cases from Dr. Henry Lee's Forensic Files: The Phil Spector Case / the Priest's Ritual Murder of a Nun / the Brown's Chicken Massacre and More! by Lee, Henry C., Labriola, Jerry M.D..

PALATINE TRAGEDY HITS HOME IN WISCONSIN TOWN

Convicted Murderer of 7 Awarded Nearly $500K - ABC News

Officer details confession in Brown's case

James Degorski

BGA Report (part 2) – IPSN

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

On the night of January 8, 1993, two armed assailants entered a Brown's Chicken restaurant in Palatine, Illinois, just before closing time and proceeded to brutally murder seven employees, all for less than $2000. There seemed to be many issues with the investigation and a lot of finger pointing at who was to blame, while the murderers remained at large. 

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

EarnIn

Download EarnIn today in the Google play or Apple app store! When you download the EarnIn app type in Creepers under PODCAST when you sign up! It really helps the show!

Brilliant Earth

Check out all their beautiful jewelry at brilliantearth.com

Sources

Book: 

Shocking Cases from Dr. Henry Lee's Forensic Files: The Phil Spector Case / the Priest's Ritual Murder of a Nun / the Brown's Chicken Massacre and More! by Lee, Henry C., Labriola, Jerry M.D..

PALATINE TRAGEDY HITS HOME IN WISCONSIN TOWN

Convicted Murderer of 7 Awarded Nearly $500K - ABC News

Officer details confession in Brown's case

James Degorski

BGA Report (part 2) – IPSN

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

It was October 12, 2012 when a very odd 911 call had come in to Campbell County dispatch. 21 year Shayna Hubers sounded frantic as she told the dispatcher she had just shot and killed her boyfriend, Ryan Poston, in self defense. But as she continued to tell her story, things just didn't seem to add up.

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

EarnIn

Download EarnIn today in the Google play or Apple app store! When you download the EarnIn app type in Creepers under PODCAST when you sign up! It really helps the show!

Brilliant Earth

Check out all their beautiful jewelry at brilliantearth.com

Sources:

Shayna Hubers retrial: Jurors shown 'gave him the nose job he wanted' police station video

Shayna Hubers trial: 'Shoot and kill him and play like it's an accident,' she texted friend

Shayna Hubers retrial: 'His life was really on a roll right then,' Poston's stepdad says

Shayna Hubers retrial: Hubers wouldn't leave Poston's condo, so he fled to father's house

Shayna Hubers on the stand: More lurid details of the couple's sex life in testimony

Shayna Hubers takes the stand: Things went downhill after refusal of sexual act, she said

Shayna Hubers retrial: Psychologist says she has borderline personality disorder

Shayna Hubers: Tears during recess after testimony on why she said she killed Ryan Poston

Bad Blood | 20/20 ABC | Full Episode

911 call: 'I killed my boyfriend in self-defense'

Shayna Hubers' texts come back to haunt her

Shayna Hubers retrial: For each text Ryan Poston sent, she sent 100

Murder of Ryan Poston - Wikipedia

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

It was August 16, 2002 when a shocking 911 call came in to police in Pohatcong, New Jersey. It was a local dentist named Roy Rambo who was calling to tell them he had just shot his wife, Linda Ann Rambo. Roy insisted he had shot his wife in self defense, but the more investigators looked into his story, the more certain they became that he was lying.

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

EarnIn

Download EarnIn today in the Google play or Apple app store! When you download the EarnIn app type in Creepers under PODCAST when you sign up! It really helps the show!

Brilliant Earth

Check out all their beautiful jewelry at brilliantearth.com

Sources: 

Roy Rambo v. Admin East Jersey State Prison

Rambo v. Nogan, Civil Action No. 14-874 (MAS) | Casetext Search + Citator

STATE OF NEW JERSEY v. ROY L. RAMBO, JR

STATE v. RAMBO (2008) | FindLaw

Judge won't reduce bail for dentist ** Pohatcong murder suspect says he can't talk to witnesses while he's locked in jail -- Morning Call

Trial date set for N.J. dentist accused of killing wife – The Morning Call

Pohatcong dentist convicted of murdering wife denied appeal - nj.com

Convicted murderer loses appeal to get marital estate funds - lehighvalleylive.com

Jury picked for murder trial of Pohatcong Twp. dentist ** Roy L. Rambo’s opening statement in case is under appeal. – The Morning Call

Murder suspect to represent self ** Pohatcong dentist accused of killing wife has had four lawyers.

Judge: Murder suspect will have to speak for himself

Dentist tells jury his wife threatened him ** Pohatcong man argues self-defense on first day of homicide trial.

Pohatcong dentist rejects plea bargain in murder case - The Morning Call

N.J. judge delays pretrial hearing in homicide ** Attorney to prepare for defense of dentist accused of killing wife. – The Morning Call

Rambo: Wife was unarmed when slain

Considerations to Use Extreme Cruelty to File for Divorce in NJ

“I just didn’t want to die,’ Pohatcong dentist says ** Roy Rambo tells jury he shot wife after she threatened him. – The Morning Call

Judge’s illness stalls Pohatcong dentist’s homicide trial ** Rambo was to present the defense’s case in his wife’s death. – The Morning Call

Assistant testifies Rambo’s slain wife was “happy’ ** Detective tells court Pohatcong dentist demonstrated the shot. – The Morning Call

DNA test shows gun struck dentist’s wife ** Specialists at Rambo’s homicide trial say her blood was on his pistol. – The Morning Call

Friends recount last day of Pohatcong dentist’s slain wife – The Morning Call

Pohatcong dentist gets 40 years for wife’s slaying ** Ray Rambo blamed legal system and said he was threatened.

Specialist confirms Linda Rambo died from gunshot ** He testifies gun held by Pohatcong husband killed her, not his blows.

Jury selection begins in trial of dentist ** Pohatcong resident accused of killing wife in his office in 2002.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

She's baaaack! Mogab has returned from her wedding break, and to welcome her back Kristin finally tells her the story she's been requesting since starting this podcast: the story behind the Toddville Murder Mansion. It's gone down in hometown lore in the Houston suburb of Seabrook, Texas - it's the story of what happens when a registered sex offender makes enough money to build a monstrosity he calls a mansion and spends his weekends preying on young people.

Sponsored By:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

Who Killed Mia?

Get 20% off with promo code CREEPERS at Relatable.com/whokilledmia

Brilliant Earth

Check out all their beautiful jewelry at brilliantearth.com

Sources: 

Book:

Murder and Mayhem in Houston by Mike Vance and John Nova Lomax

From the Houston Chronicle archive: The street that led to murder

List’s ‘retirement home’ to be a mansion | Ralph Bivins | The Daily Citizen | June 5, 1980

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Mogab got married last weekend!!!! So naturally we had to take a week off for all the celebrations! In our absence, I hope you enjoy this episode from the vault (aka our Patreon bonus episodes!)

When detectives in Somerset County, New Jersey receive information about suspicious deaths at a hospital, they come to the horrific realization that a nurse is intentionally killing his patients. They are ready to work together with the hospital to identify and arrest whoever is responsible, but are shocked to find that the hospital stonewalls them at every point of their investigation. As patients continue to die in sudden and suspicious ways, the detectives realize they are out of time, and to solve their case they are going to need the help of a brave woman willing to risk it all to take down a serial killer. 

Sponsored By:

Hello Fresh

Go to HelloFresh.com/50creepers and and use code 50creepers for 50% off plus free shipping!

Who Killed Mia?

Get 20% off with promo code CREEPERS at Relatable.com/whokilledmia

Brilliant Earth

Check out all their beautiful jewelry at brilliantearth.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices