The Insurance Buzz

373. Rebuilding After a $6.5M Loss: Cole’s Blueprint for Massive Comebacks


Listen Later

📢 COMING SOON: 24/7 Sales Coaching for Your Team

We're launching something big—and only 100 agencies will get in.

Imagine real-time coaching, feedback, and call reviews for every producer—without you lifting a finger. 👉 Text "AI" to (816) 727-7610 to join the waitlist.

What’s in this episode:                                                                                                                     

After losing $6.5 million in premium in just 24 months, most agency owners would’ve tapped out. But Cole Caughern rebuilt—smarter. Michael and Courtney unpack the comeback: how he shifted his mindset, reorganized his team, and built a lean, high-performing sales engine.

You’ll learn why Cole ditched one-size-fits-all sales roles, how he uses data to cut waste, and what he looks for in top producers. Whether you're rebuilding or scaling, this episode is a blueprint for building a resilient, specialized team

 [00:00] The $6.5M premium loss that sparked the rebuild
 [02:30] Why hiring generalists was hurting production
 [05:00] Building a specialized sales team (and why it works)
 [07:30] Why the best reps only do one thing—and crush it
 [12:00] Starting over: physically easier, emotionally harder
 [14:00] What Cole would do differently in a cold market
 [18:00] How to spot warning signs before the market shifts
 [20:00] The moment things turned around—and what changed
 [23:00] His next strategy: in-person events + QR-to-quote pipeline
 [25:00] Hiring based on strengths, not just roles
 [27:30] Retaining top producers by aligning with passion
 [30:00] The 3 metrics Cole uses to measure daily performance
 [32:00] Why quoting more doesn’t fix your close rate
 [34:00] Stop plugging holes with Flex Seal—track the right data
 [37:00] How to get your team real-time coaching (without being in the room)

📱 Connect with Cole Caughern:  HERE

 ▶️ Watch the full episode on YouTube: HERE

BOOK A DEMO– Agency Coach AI Learn More: Let's Chat https://agencycoachai.com

The first 24/7 AI sales coaching platform built for insurance pros. Real-time grading, role plays, and coaching that help producers close more deals.

TEXT MICHAEL DIRECTLY
Have a question or want to talk to Michael directly? It’s really him, not a robot. Text “BUZZ” to (816) 727-7610

FREE 7-Day Demo – Weaver Sales Academy
Try it: CLICK HERE

Tools + Free Resources
https://www.weaversa.com

Connect with Michael Online
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/michaelweaverwsa
YouTube: @michaelweavertraining
Facebook: facebook.com/themichaelweaver
Instagram: @michaelweaver

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Insurance BuzzBy Michael and Courtney Weaver

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

126 ratings


More shows like The Insurance Buzz

View all
The Ramsey Show by Ramsey Network

The Ramsey Show

39,205 Listeners

Life.Church with Craig Groeschel by Life.Church

Life.Church with Craig Groeschel

3,480 Listeners

Joel Osteen Podcast by Joel Osteen, SiriusXM

Joel Osteen Podcast

24,541 Listeners

Ramsey Everyday Millionaires by Ramsey Network

Ramsey Everyday Millionaires

3,693 Listeners

THE ED MYLETT SHOW by Ed Mylett | Cumulus Podcast Network

THE ED MYLETT SHOW

14,009 Listeners

The Insurance Guys Podcast by Scott Howell & Bradley Flowers

The Insurance Guys Podcast

204 Listeners

The Insurance Dudes© by The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman

The Insurance Dudes©

168 Listeners

A Bit of Optimism by Simon Sinek

A Bit of Optimism

2,211 Listeners

Huberman Lab by Scicomm Media

Huberman Lab

29,360 Listeners

Millionaire Insurance Producer by Charles Specht

Millionaire Insurance Producer

41 Listeners

Insurance Producers Podcast by Cyrus Jaffery

Insurance Producers Podcast

5 Listeners

The Mel Robbins Podcast by Mel Robbins

The Mel Robbins Podcast

21,096 Listeners

The Candace Cameron Bure Podcast by CandyRock

The Candace Cameron Bure Podcast

3,937 Listeners

The Dr. Josh Axe Show by Dr. Josh Axe

The Dr. Josh Axe Show

1,401 Listeners

The Scratch Agency Podcast by The Scratch Agency Podcast

The Scratch Agency Podcast

21 Listeners