Lives Less Ordinary

Could a sitcom save a man from death row?


Listen Later

Juan Catalan was facing the death penalty for a murder he didn’t commit. There was one man he thought could save him: US comedian Larry David.

On 12 May 2003, Juan attended a baseball game that he would later say saved his life. It was his local team, the LA Dodgers, versus the Atlanta Braves. The game was exciting, but unremarkable for Juan – apart from a television crew that was filming in his section.

Three months later, Juan arrived at work only to be surrounded by undercover police and arrested in front of his girlfriend and daughter. It was several hours before Juan found out he had been charged with the murder of a 16-year-old girl called Martha Puebla. It was a crime that carried the death penalty. Juan protested his innocence, and later realised he had been at the baseball game the night of her murder. Perhaps, he thought, he could prove his alibi if he had been caught on camera by that TV production.

Eventually, Juan's lawyer Todd Melnik figured out that the show in question was Curb Your Enthusiasm, created by comedian Larry David. The network HBO finally let Todd view the tapes, which contained a direct shot of Juan. But the footage was filmed well before the murder was committed, so Todd had to keep searching for evidence to exonerate Juan. In the end, it was cell tower records that proved Juan could not have killed Martha Puebla.

Since his case was dismissed, Juan has gone on to write a memoir called Played and Todd and Juan's relationship has also blossomed into a friendship. They have even attended Dodgers games together.

Credits: Curb Your Enthusiasm/Whyaduck Productions in association with HBO Entertainment/Jeff Schaffer and Robert B. Weide

Presenter: Jo Fidgen

Producer: Saskia Collette

Lives Less Ordinary is a podcast from the BBC World Service that brings you the most incredible true stories from around the world. Each episode a guest shares their most dramatic, moving, personal story. Listen for unbelievable twists, mysteries uncovered, and inspiring journeys - spanning the entire human experience. Step into someone else’s life and expect the unexpected.

 
Got a story to tell? Send an email to [email protected] or message us via WhatsApp: 0044 330 678 2784
 
You can read our privacy notice here:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/5YD3hBqmw26B8WMHt6GkQxG/lives-less-ordinary-privacy-notice

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Lives Less OrdinaryBy BBC World Service

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

469 ratings


More shows like Lives Less Ordinary

View all
Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,716 Listeners

From Our Own Correspondent by BBC Radio 4

From Our Own Correspondent

375 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,063 Listeners

Woman's Hour by BBC Radio 4

Woman's Hour

379 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,537 Listeners

The Documentary Podcast by BBC World Service

The Documentary Podcast

1,800 Listeners

Witness History by BBC World Service

Witness History

961 Listeners

The History Hour by BBC World Service

The History Hour

587 Listeners

6 Minute English by BBC Radio

6 Minute English

1,768 Listeners

Learning English Conversations by BBC Radio

Learning English Conversations

1,035 Listeners

Desert Island Discs by BBC Radio 4

Desert Island Discs

2,020 Listeners

The Food Chain by BBC World Service

The Food Chain

342 Listeners

File on 4 Investigates by BBC Radio 4

File on 4 Investigates

39 Listeners

The Inquiry by BBC World Service

The Inquiry

732 Listeners

The Audio Long Read by The Guardian

The Audio Long Read

843 Listeners

People Fixing the World by BBC World Service

People Fixing the World

241 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,168 Listeners

The Missing Cryptoqueen by BBC Sounds

The Missing Cryptoqueen

1,005 Listeners

The Slow Newscast by The Observer

The Slow Newscast

161 Listeners

The Bomb by BBC World Service

The Bomb

1,003 Listeners

Life Changing by BBC Radio 4

Life Changing

113 Listeners

The History Podcast by BBC Radio 4

The History Podcast

58 Listeners

Strangers on a Bench by Tom Rosenthal

Strangers on a Bench

767 Listeners