Born Free Method: The Podcast

Hermine Hayes: Birthing autonomy is the struggle of midwives for legal recognition and patient rights.


Listen Later

Hermine discusses the tragic incident where the baby died during the home birth and the aftermath that the family and their midwife faced. Hermine argues that home births are treated as a normal healthcare choice in many countries, but in the United States, doctors have the power to make that choice questionable. In this case, the baby did not survive and the doctors called the police on the parents upon arrival at the hospital. The family and their midwife were interrogated and had their homes raided, causing them to go through a traumatic experience. Hermine highlights the double standard between the treatment of home birth midwives versus obstetricians and calls for more integration of home births into the healthcare system.

Visit the show notes for more.

Learn More & Connect with Hermine Hayes:

  • Website
  • Linkedin

In this episode:

[5:00] Women will choose to give birth where they feel safest, regardless of the law.

  • In states where out-of-hospital births are not regulated, they continue to occur.
  • Out-of-hospital birth underground does not change the choice.

[14:00] Birthing women have the right to make decisions about their care.

  • Respecting these rights is crucial to avoid coercion and ensure patient autonomy.
  • They have the right to refuse offers of treatment, including cesarean surgery.

[23:00] The standard of care for a lay midwife differs from that of an ob-gyn or nurse midwife.

  • Negligent child abuse resulting in death is a specific charge with a legal definition.
  • The term "negligent" can have different meanings in different contexts.

[32:00] Even when something doesn't feel right, it can impact women’s ability to make informed decisions.

  • The state may be working to make hospital births the only option, punishing midwives.
  • Informed consent in maternity care has been distorted.

[41:00] Women are conditioned to be agreeable, which affects their decision-making process during vulnerable times like childbirth.

  • Detaching from this conditioning can be challenging, but important to do so.
  • Empathy is a valuable trait, and not be taken advantage of in medical situations. 

[50:00] Medicine, especially in obstetrics, is a privilege that must be approached with respect and empathy.

  • Healthcare providers must examine their actions toward their patients to ensure they are not violating their rights.
  • Healthcare providers should create a culture of informed consent and respect for patients' bodily autonomy.

This episode was made possible by:

  • FullWell - code BELOVED10 for 10% off the best prenatal vitamins and men's virility vitamins on the planet!
  • BIRTHFIT - code BELOVED to get one month FREE in their B! Community!
  • BiOptimizers - code BELOVED for 10% off the only sleep aid you'll ever need!


  • Get full access to Born Free Method: The Podcast at nathanrileyobgyn.substack.com/subscribe
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Born Free Method: The PodcastBy Nathan Riley

  • 4.2
  • 4.2
  • 4.2
  • 4.2
  • 4.2

4.2

331 ratings


More shows like Born Free Method: The Podcast

View all
Fertility Friday | Fertility Awareness Mastery for Women's Health Professionals by Lisa Hendrickson-Jack, FAE, HRHP

Fertility Friday | Fertility Awareness Mastery for Women's Health Professionals

795 Listeners

The Birth Hour - A Birth Story Podcast by Bryn Huntpalmer

The Birth Hour - A Birth Story Podcast

2,154 Listeners

On Health for Women by Aviva Romm

On Health for Women

1,356 Listeners

Wise Traditions by Weston A. Price Foundation w/ Hilda Labrada Gore

Wise Traditions

2,300 Listeners

Free Birth Society by Emilee Saldaya

Free Birth Society

1,206 Listeners

Evidence Based Birth® by Rebecca Dekker, PhD, RN

Evidence Based Birth®

1,013 Listeners

Happy Homebirth by Katelyn Fusco

Happy Homebirth

555 Listeners

Pregnancy & Birth Made Easy by My Essential Birth

Pregnancy & Birth Made Easy

716 Listeners

Down to Birth by Cynthia Overgard & Trisha Ludwig

Down to Birth

527 Listeners

Culture Apothecary with Alex Clark by Turning Point USA

Culture Apothecary with Alex Clark

12,931 Listeners

Birthing Instincts by Dr. Stuart Fischbein + Midwife Blyss Young

Birthing Instincts

631 Listeners

The Modern Ancestral Mamas Podcast by Corey Dunn and Christine Muldoon

The Modern Ancestral Mamas Podcast

145 Listeners

The Wildly Capable Show by Liz and Joey Haselmayer

The Wildly Capable Show

496 Listeners

Reclamation Radio with Kelly Brogan MD by Kelly Brogan MD

Reclamation Radio with Kelly Brogan MD

412 Listeners

Pain Free Birth by Karen Welton

Pain Free Birth

136 Listeners