
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
I’d love to hear your thoughts on this.
What do you think, does our language express or create the “I?”
The rules of our language identify a subject and a verb. For example, an I and something that is happening.
“I am doing this.”
Yet in this conversation it is seen that awareness is aware of the doing happening — I am not doing this. I am not the doer and there is no I.)
Does the world look this way in language because this is how we think or do we think this way because of our language?
It may ultimately be a chicken and an egg thing, or just a case of co-arising.
But I wonder are there cultures/languages with sentences that developed without a subject?
It feels like there is an intuitive sense of an I, but babies don’t seem to be born with it. Helen Keller, I’ve read, had no sense of an I or a self until she learned language. Or until language was learned by that localized body/mind system.
I don’t know the attribution, but I’ve recently heard “The I in I am happy is the same as the it in it is raining.”
How much does language shape our thinking? Or does our thinking shape our language?
5
4242 ratings
I’d love to hear your thoughts on this.
What do you think, does our language express or create the “I?”
The rules of our language identify a subject and a verb. For example, an I and something that is happening.
“I am doing this.”
Yet in this conversation it is seen that awareness is aware of the doing happening — I am not doing this. I am not the doer and there is no I.)
Does the world look this way in language because this is how we think or do we think this way because of our language?
It may ultimately be a chicken and an egg thing, or just a case of co-arising.
But I wonder are there cultures/languages with sentences that developed without a subject?
It feels like there is an intuitive sense of an I, but babies don’t seem to be born with it. Helen Keller, I’ve read, had no sense of an I or a self until she learned language. Or until language was learned by that localized body/mind system.
I don’t know the attribution, but I’ve recently heard “The I in I am happy is the same as the it in it is raining.”
How much does language shape our thinking? Or does our thinking shape our language?
1,839 Listeners
12,515 Listeners
147 Listeners
4,030 Listeners
608 Listeners
264 Listeners
26,930 Listeners
3,763 Listeners
243 Listeners
1,336 Listeners
7 Listeners
872 Listeners
1,347 Listeners
2,002 Listeners
20,349 Listeners