PART 2

In this second episode, Nightshift's Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders get into the details. We walk you through the scene of the crime, autopsy reports, and Jeff Pelley's narrow timeline, to include any and all alibis and witness statements

_________________

They originally thought the victims' skin was littered with lacerations. Soon, however, they realized it was the collateral damage from all of the fragmented pieces of bone that had flown through the air.

Bob Pelley secured a lucrative job overseeing the computer processor hub for a well known financial institution and living in Cape Coral, Florida.

His children, a boy and a girl, were young. The oldest was only 13 when his mother passed after a rather quick illness. Bob stayed on with the bank for a while longer, and in the meantime, found a lady who had also experienced recently losing a spouse. They hit it off and wed months later. But palm trees and pool life were not long for their world.

In what some have called a very abrupt move, Bob took a deep pay cut to follow his heart as a preacher - all the way up in Indiana in a town with under 700 people.

The families merged, and everyone had adjusting to do. But as Bob's oldest son, Jeff, sat back and waited for graduation, things at the Pelley home took a turn.

Was an argument over prom enough to cause a teenage boy to snap and leave the house in a coat of blood?

OR were the witness statements that were not admissible to court, what the murders actually hinged on? Did Bob in fact leave some secrets behind in Florida?

Tune into Nightshift to hear Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders launch into the second part of this saga. Watch Nightshift live on Tuesday nights on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream audio podcasts. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all!

#slain #spatter #promnight #circumstancial #snapped #pelley #capecoral

PART 1 of 2

They originally thought their skin was littered with lacerations. Soon, however, they realized it was the collateral damage from all of the fragmented pieces of bone that had flown through the air.

Bob Pelley secured a lucrative job overseeing the computer processor hub for a well known financial institution and living in Cape Coral, Florida.

His children, a boy and a girl, were young. The oldest was only 13 when his mother passed after a rather quick illness. Bob stayed on with the bank for a while longer, and in the meantime, found a lady who had also experienced recently losing a spouse. They hit it off and wed months later. But palm trees and pool life were not long for their world.

In what some have called a very abrupt move, Bob took a deep pay cut to follow his heart as a preacher - all the way up in Indiana in a town with under 700 people.

The families merged, and everyone had adjusting to do. But as Bob's oldest son, Jeff, sat back and waited for graduation, things at the Pelley home took a turn.

Was an argument over prom enough to cause a teenage boy to snap and leave the house in a coat of blood?

OR were the witness statements that were not admissible to court, what the murders actually hinged on? Did Bob in fact leave some secrets behind in Florida?

Tune into Nightshift to hear Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders set up this story for part 1, and then get into the details for part 2. Watch Nightshift live on Tuesday nights on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream audio podcasts. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all!

#slain #spatter #promnight #circumstancial #snapped #pelley #capecoral

Two days later, she got a package in the mail....Nieko Lisi was 18 years old in 2011. In the fall of that year, amidst a variety of friends and acquaintances, he seemed to vanish. But little by little, a story began to come together. State lines were crossed and a trail was revealed. But cell phone pings, witness statements, and harassing behavior only made his family more determined to find out exactly what happened in early October. As soon as it seemed every stone had been turned, a major discovery took place many states away. And then another. What had been a missing person's case for years has turned into an active investigation. And tonight, his mother is going to tell you all about it. Join Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders as Nightshift once again talks to you about Nieko Lisi, and learn how his family has fought for nearly 15 years. Watch Nightshift live on Tuesdays on the Andrea Up Late channel, and listen wherever you stream podcasts. Follow on IG @andreauplate. Email any questions or requests to [email protected]. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all!#vanished #missing #investigate #TN #slain

#searchforniekolisi

"Ok you can go, but be home by six."

Words Julie Moseley's mother regretted for 43 years until her death in 2017.

It was Christmas time in Ft. Worth, Texas and it was 1974. Bell bottoms, promise rings, and the hopes of Santa's favor was in the air.

Three young girls, the youngest only 9, had a day of mall shopping ahead. Christmas was only two days away and their excitement was palpable.

The girls had specific times to arrive home, so when those times came and went, their families became increasingly concerned.

But they didn't show. The next day a bizarre letter arrives to one of their homes. Witnesses began coming forward with horrific accounts of vans, trucks, strange men, and demands. But what is the true story?

Rachel Trlica, Renee Wilson, and Julie Moseley were last seen at the Seminary South shopping center on December 23, 1974 - and not a trace of them has been seen since.

Join Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders to listen to a case that leaves every question *almost* unanswered.

Watch Nightshift every Tuesday night live on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream podcasts. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE - it's free, y'all!

Reach out with questions or case requests to Instagram at andrea_up_late, or email [email protected].

Have you ever seen a bullet travel backward?

Christian Andreacchio was an energetic, ambitious 21 year old in 2014. Poised to be the youngest tugboat captain in the history of Magnolia Marine, he spent nearly as much time on the water as he did on land.

After his girlfriend, Whitley, was forced to move from his family home for an egregious act, Christian followed suit and they, together, moved into his brother's apartment.

But during Christian's time away, Whitley Goodman lived quite a life for a 17 year old girl. After all, she had free room and board, and, most recently - a gifted BMW from Christian.

A fake pregnancy, life insurance questions, and a night spent with another man, eventually toppled this house of cards.

Unfortunately, Christian fell first.

What does a fast food receipt and a bank visit have to do with all of this?

Join Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders as they discuss this criminal conundrum.

Watch Nightshift live every Tuesday night live on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Follow on Instagram at andrea_up_late. Listen wherever you stream podcasts. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all.

*Message us on any platform, or email [email protected] for case requests or questions.

It was September 2, 2010, and Michelle O'Connell was excited for the Paramore concert that night at the St. Augustine Amphitheater in Florida. Her sister was babysitting Michelle's daughter, four year old Alexis. But Michelle knew she had even bigger plans that evening.

Michelle and Alexis had lived with Deputy Jeremy Banks for the past year. What started as a hopeful romance, turned into quite the opposite. Amidst complaints of violence to her family and friends, Jennifer was making plans to leave. And she planned to do that just after the concert that night.

However within just an hour of their travels back to the residence, Michelle would be dead.

A 911 call placed by Jeremy is a great study in emotion and voice detection.

He states that Michelle ended her own life, while he waited in his garage for her to pack her things. In fact, he states she did so with his own duty pistol. Yes, the pistol on his belt, in a retention holster, that he used for work. Coworkers of Jeremy's arrived to assess the situation.

Evidence was collected, minimally. Interviews were conducted, light heartedly. The sheriff was offended - greatly.

This case required special prosecution appointments, governor involvement, and administrative leave. But not where you may expect it. Then after the family fought for YEARS, Michelle's body was exhumed. What was found that had never been reported?? The figurative nail in the coffin. But why hasn't her manner of death ever been changed?

Oh, let's not forget the next civilian to investigate Michelle's death....as he got closer, the man was made to stop in his tracks. By being murdered. Another murder yet unsolved.

Join Andrea Up Late and retired homicide Lieutenant, Brian Sanders, as they untangle this web of medical examiners, botched statements, and a belligerent sheriff.

Let us know what you think. Watch Nightshift every live every Tuesday on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream podcasts. Follow on Instagram at andreauplate. Message case recommendations or thoughts to IG, or email at [email protected]. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all.

#mystery #unsolvedcases #sheriff #domestic_violence #staugustine #staugustinelife #staugustineflorida #nightshift #nurse

Just north of Nashville, in the small town of Cross Plains, Tennessee, Jennifer Wix was becoming a wonderful mother. It was 2004 and her beautiful daughter, Adrianna, had just turned two years old. While Jennifer had previous plans to obtain work in either equine therapy or as a park ranger, sadly she was now making plans to escape an unsafe home.

Jennifer was living at the time with her boyfriend, Joey Benton, and his parents. Parties got wilder, Joey's temper got shorter, and his parents had increasing animosity toward Jennifer and her daughter. During one of her last interactions with Joey's mother, Jennifer and Adrianna's food was thrown on the ground outside and she was instructed to go "eat like the dogs do."

The only thing we know with certainty in the moments leading up to the disappearance of the two girls, is that Adrianna had a new and concerning diagnosis, and Jennifer had decided fully that she would not be spending another night under that roof. But did she ever get the chance to escape?

Neither she nor Adrianna have ever been seen again.

BUT:

In over two decades, Joey hasn't spoken. He maintained from the start that he dropped them both off at a gas station, with an unknown person. But his information was contradictory at best, and simply untrue. And then just last year, after his father went to jail on unrelated charges, Joes decided it was time.

He. Spoke.

And you won't believe it.

Weapons charges, alibis that don't align, domestic violence, and the retrieval of a decomposing human leg....

How is this story going to end?

Join Andrea Up Late as she and Brian Sanders walk you through the events that led to the monumental updates that just happened last month.

Watch Nightshift on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel every Tuesday night. Listen wherever you stream audio podcasts. Send requests or any communication via messaging on IG to the andrea_up_late page, or email at: [email protected].

Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all!

#missing #jenniferwix #adriannawix #dv #tbi #tennesseebureauofinvestigation #benton #slain #truecrime #nightshift #nurse

In 1974, in a suburb of Houston, children were brimming with excitement to go trick or treating the night of Halloween. Ronald O'Bryan offered to take his children out, as rain was immanent, and his wife was happy to stay back and pass out candy to the children coming by the house. Ronald and his two children were accompanied by a family friend and his two children. But what started as a night of giggling children skipping through the streets, ended in tragedy. This is the case that caused your parents to look through your Halloween candy. It is the night when a real life boogeyman plagued a town, or at least, a family.Join Andrea Up Late and retired homicide lieutenant, Brian Sanders, as they discuss this case for the yearly Halloween show. Come chat with us!Watch Nightshift live weekly on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream podcasts. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, yall!Follow on IG on the andrea_up_late page. Reach out with case recommendations. #halloween #candyman #murder #candy #houston #ruecrime #nurse #nightshift

Jennifer Pandos was a sophomore in high school in 1987. She had friends, loved art, and an on and off again love interest. In February of 1987, Jennifer was on the phone with a close friend one night. The call ended abruptly when Jennifer's father was heard yelling at her to get off the phone. Jennifer was never seen or heard of outside of her home, ever again. Jennifer's brother, Stephen Pandos, has long been convinced that his father had everything to do with his sister's disappearance. Ron Pandos suffered from PTSD after a tour in Vietnam, and Stephen recounts a childhood in which he endured beatings. Some also look to her love interest, Tony Tobler. They had been through alot together at such a young age. Long lost love notes suggested anger, aggression and bruises left behind. Speaking of left behind...what should be made of the incredibly bizarre note left on Jennifer's bed at the time of her disappearance? Watch Nightshift every Tuesday on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream audio podcasts. Email at [email protected], and follow on IG at andrea_up_late. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free!#jenniferpandos #burdenofproof #missing #murdered

BREAKING UPDATES: We discuss Ellen Greenberg's case again, with the most recent updates after the HULU documentary. Ellen Greenberg's life ended in her apartment on January 26, 2011. The 27 year old first grade teacher was engaged, had a close family, and dear friends. But on that afternoon, as a blizzard changed the afternoon's events, Ellen lain propped against the kitchen cabinets. Her Uggs and sweatpants were drenched with blood, glasses strewn bedside her on the floor, and a knife was plunged in her chest almost four inches deep. This was only one of the 23 knife wounds to her chest, neck, abdomen, head, and back of the neck. Ellen also had over 50 bruises in various stages of healing. But her fiancé was in the apartment gym when it happened. See, she chose to end her life this way while he was gone for 40 min. Well, that's what the medical examiners in Pennsylvania want you to believe. That's right. Secret meetings, pressure from the DA's office, an Attorney General's office turning a blind eye...the list goes on. Ellen's fiancé was fully lawyered up (recommended it seems, by his uncle who is a notable lawyer in the state). The same uncle that retrieved all of Ellen's laptops and phone mere hours after her death. After a series of civil court cases and multiple independent autopsy reviews, a documentary that dropped last week, and a settlement, Ellen's parents received the results from the latest autopsy review from the state's examiner. You won't believe what it said.Join Andrea Up Late and Brian Sanders as they discuss the case that has everybody questioning not only the events of that day in January, but how in the world this conclusion can be made after seeing the wounds on Ellen's body. Watch nightshift every Tuesday on the Andrea Up Late YouTube channel. Listen wherever you stream audio podcasts. Follow andrea_up_late on IG and see pictures from the show. Like, rate, review, and SUBSCRIBE. It's free, y'all. #ellengreenberg #apartment603 #samgoldberg #pennsylvania #marionosbourne #joshshapiro #hulu #murder #nightshift #truecrime #medicalexaminer