The Argument

Should It Be This Hard to Sue the Police and Win?

Listen Later

One of the strongest calls for police reform is to end a legal doctrine called qualified immunity. Advocates for change argue it would be one of the most immediate ways to hold officers more accountable for their actions. But critics say it would leave police vulnerable when they’re faced with life-threatening situations.

Qualified immunity protects government officials from some lawsuits if they violate a person’s constitutional rights in the course of their duties. If you’ve heard of police officers getting away with unconstitutional behavior and wondered how, it might have been because they had qualified immunity.

This week, Jane Coaston talks to two lawyers who strongly disagree about whether qualified immunity needs to go. Lenny Kesten is a leading defender of police officers with Brody Hardoon Perkins & Kesten, and Easha Anand is the Supreme Court and appellate counsel for the MacArthur Justice Center.

Mentioned in this episode:

“The Cops Who Killed Tony Timpa Are Unfit to Serve. But Courts Ensure They Keep Their Jobs” by James Craven at the Cato Institute

“Police Responded to His 911 Call for Help, He Died. What Happened to Tony Timpa?” in The Dallas Morning News

The decision in the Timpa v. Dillard case

“Qualified Immunity: A Debate” hosted by the Federalist Society

Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store
The ArgumentBy New York Times Opinion
  • 2.8
  • 2.8
  • 2.8
  • 2.8
  • 2.8

2.8

20 ratings

More shows like The Argument

View all
The Book Review by The New York Times

The Book Review

3,863 Listeners

Popcast by The New York Times

Popcast

1,451 Listeners

The Political Scene | The New Yorker by WNYC Studios and The New Yorker

The Political Scene | The New Yorker

3,911 Listeners

The New Yorker Radio Hour by WNYC Studios and The New Yorker

The New Yorker Radio Hour

6,679 Listeners

Modern Love by The New York Times

Modern Love

8,840 Listeners

Inside The Times by The New York Times

Inside The Times

130 Listeners

The Run-Up by The New York Times

The Run-Up

2,065 Listeners

The Daily by The New York Times

The Daily

110,845 Listeners

Change Agent by The New York Times

Change Agent

1,498 Listeners

Caliphate by The New York Times

Caliphate

12,625 Listeners

Charm City by The New York Times

Charm City

303 Listeners

Interesting Times with Ross Douthat by New York Times Opinion

Interesting Times with Ross Douthat

6,965 Listeners

Post Reports by The Washington Post

Post Reports

5,410 Listeners

The Latest by The New York Times

The Latest

469 Listeners

The Candidates by The New York Times

The Candidates

52 Listeners

Jungle Prince by The New York Times

Jungle Prince

2,321 Listeners

The Choice by New York Times Opinion

The Choice

380 Listeners

Sugar Calling by The New York Times

Sugar Calling

1,450 Listeners

Rabbit Hole by The New York Times

Rabbit Hole

6,672 Listeners

Hard Fork by The New York Times

Hard Fork

5,448 Listeners

The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

The Ezra Klein Show

15,470 Listeners

Day X by The New York Times

Day X

1,493 Listeners

The Interview by The New York Times

The Interview

1,481 Listeners

The Run-Up (2016) by The New York Times

The Run-Up (2016)

7 Listeners

Sway by New York Times Opinion

Sway

66 Listeners

First Person by The New York Times

First Person

10 Listeners

The Headlines by The New York Times

The Headlines

512 Listeners

The Opinions by The New York Times Opinion

The Opinions

455 Listeners

The Run-Up Guide to 2024 by The New York Times

The Run-Up Guide to 2024

0 Listeners

The New York Times Narrated by The New York Times

The New York Times Narrated

49 Listeners