When the elderly spouse of a registered nurse is found dead in their bed, do you investigate further or just assume they passed away peacefully in their sleep? Listen as Melissa tells Daniel a case out of rural Kentucky. Where the convalescent homes outnumber the churches. This episode might leave you scratching your head and asking, "but why?".
We hope you enjoy.
Case begins at 12:00
*We completely forgot to do Patreon shoutouts for this episode. We will do double next episode.

Send us a text

Support the show

The MacArthur’s are giving you a sneak peak into their newest spin-off show called “To Have and To Kill” normally only available to Patreon subscribers (feel free to attack our character and our desire to formulate a little bit of an income). 
In this show Melissa tells Daniel cases of couples who murder… together. 
Episode 3 is that of the case of “The Lonely Hearts Killers” Raymond Fernandez and Martha Beck. This case is wild!
Since this is a Patreon spinoff we do not hold back as much so if we tend to “frustrate” you with our logical opinions on the facts of a case then you should probably move on. We are not changing for anybody. Call it our “Generation X” mentality or just plain stubbornness. You’ve been warned!

Send us a text

Support the show

In this episode Melissa continues her series from the book Till Death Do Us Part by Robbie Ludwig and Matt Birkbeck. Listen as Melissa does a deep dive into chapter 6 of the book called The Narcissistic Killer while Daniel listens impatiently for his turn to talk. The cases discussed within this chapter and the episode are Rabbi Fred and Carol Neulander and Gegg and Pamela Smart. We hope you enjoy!

Send us a text

Support the show

Daniel's still scratching his head over this one.

You know it's an interesting case when you have dueling forensic medical professionals, very little physical evidence, a voice from the grave, a 911 call that law enforcement deems overly dramatic, and a "swipe right" on a certain dating app. 

Did the victim die from and accidental fall? Or were they murdered? We have our opinions. Will yours be the same? Maybe not.

Send us a text

Support the show

Thank you to all who submitted stories. We will definitely be doing more of these. Happy Halloweiner!

Send us a text

Support the show

This Halloween, thirteen true crime podcasts (including us, Till Death Do Us Part Podcast)
come together to share dark and disturbing stories. From haunted houses to serial killers, these tales will send chills down your spine and keep you up at night. Join us for this special 2-part Halloween episode entitled “When Darkness Calls” as we explore the darkest corners of humanity. But be warned: these stories are not for the faint of heart. When darkness calls, how will you respond?

Listener discretion advised.

Podcasts are listed in order of appearance:
Part 1:
1) True Crime South Africa
2) True Crime Cat Lawyer
3) Private Dicks
4) Coffee and Cases
5) Teachers Talk Crime
6) Excuse me, That's Illegal
7) Fresh Hell Podcast

Part 2:
1) Twisted Travel and True Crime
2) Body To Burial
3) Till Death Do Us Part
4) Unethical
5) PNW Haunts & Homicides
6) True CrimeCast

Send us a text

Support the show

This Halloween, thirteen true crime podcasts (including us, Till Death Do Us Part Podcast)
come together to share dark and disturbing stories. From haunted houses to serial killers, these tales will send chills down your spine and keep you up at night. Join us for this special 2-part Halloween episode entitled “When Darkness Calls” as we explore the darkest corners of humanity. But be warned: these stories are not for the faint of heart. When darkness calls, how will you respond?

Listener discretion advised.

Podcasts are listed in order of appearance:
Part 1:
1) True Crime South Africa
2) True Crime Cat Lawyer
3) Private Dicks
4) Coffee and Cases
5) Teachers Talk Crime
6) Excuse me, That's Illegal
7) Fresh Hell Podcast

Part 2:
1) Twisted Travel and True Crime
2) Body To Burial
3) Till Death Do Us Part
4) Unethical
5) PNW Haunts & Homicides
6) True CrimeCast

Send us a text

Support the show

Listen as the MacArthur's take you for a walk down memory lane as Melissa tells Daniel a few of New Orleans most famous haunts. Including the legend of Julie, Pirates Alley, Lafitte's Blacksmith Shop Bar, and the LaLaurie Mansion. You might think you know the legends and the lore but having been on at least 10 Haunted History Tours of the French Quarter in the last 20 years, this dysfunctional couple might just have the inside scoop.
*** The purple drink is called a Voodoo Daquiri!!!***
PS- We talk about ourselves a lot in this episode. You've been warned!

Send us a text

Support the show

Listen as Melissa tells Daniel a case with 3 guilty convictions and multiple appeals. Should a letter from beyond the grave be admitted into evidence? Or do the words of the dead have no bearing?
Case begins at 14:30. Enjoy!

Send us a text

Support the show

Listen as Melissa tells Daniel the case that shook the early 2000's. Was this a case of self-defense or was the murder premeditated? You might come away changing your tune a few times. Daniel sure did.
Thank you to Kristy J. and Megan B. for the case recommendation.
Case begins at 9:00

Send us a text

Support the show