November 03, 2025

28. Building a Sticky Membership Community Members Want to Stay In [Practical Tips & Strategies to Use ASAP]

34 minutes

FREE 3-Day Workshop (Nov 24–26): In Her Community Era

— 100 Free Tickets + Grand Prize 

One attendee will win 1 year of VIP Milli inside Million Dollar Memberships Club (>$4,000 value).

🤍🪩 GET YOUR TICKET BEFORE THEY’RE GONE: https://paigevandy.com/in-her-community-era

JOIN THE WAITLIST: Million Dollar Memberships Club is Opening to the Waitlist November 17.

Join the waitlist now and get an instant email highlighting our Black Friday deals PLUS lock in an exclusive WAITLIST ONLY price + bonus

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

FREE On-Demand 35-Minute Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 7-Figure Online Membership (even from zero) https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

In this episode, Paige shares practical, no-fluff strategies to transform a quiet, creator-dependent membership into a sticky, self-sustaining community. You’ll learn how to shift from “audience” to community, engineer member-to-member connection, set healthy founder boundaries, and build a simple retention cadence members actually feel. If your community feels quiet or your members only engage with you (not each other), this one’s going to hit. 🖤

You’ll discover:

Audience vs. Community: Why your job is to spark member-to-member connection (not more content) — and how to do it weekly.

The First 48 Hours: A simple onboarding protocol to ensure every new member bonds with another member fast.

Monthly Retention Rhythm: The “26th of the month” tease and other ways to prime next-month stickiness.

Success Paths > Stuff: Show members a clear path to results so they don’t feel overwhelmed or bored by a content dump.

Boundary-Led Leadership: How to set expectations (when you’re in the community, where personal support happens) so you can scale without being the glue.

Why Less Can Convert More: The real reason “more content” isn’t the answer to engagement or results — and what to build instead.

🪩 Special Invite — In Her Community Era (Nov 24–26)  This free 3-day workshop is for new and established membership founders who want consistent sales, a lively community, and systems to run it like a true founder — without launching every month.

Day 1: Consistent membership sales (without monthly launches)

Day 2: What to actually include in your membership (and what to cut)

Day 3: Run & scale like a founder (systems, show-up plans, front- and back-end selling) 

Grand prize: 1 year of VIP Milli inside MDMC to one participant.

 👉 Use the first link above to claim your free ticket (100 available).

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast

Free Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?  Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies, templates, and community to build a profitable, culture-driven membership. 

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Already growing and want hands-on strategy? 

Work with Paige 1:1 (limited). Email [email protected].

Connect With Paige

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse 

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build profitable memberships and escape the 1:1 hustle.

You’ll learn proven strategies to launch and scale, keep members engaged month after month, and turn your community into a reliable recurring-revenue machine. If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy, and The Art of Online Business, you’ll feel right at home here. 🤍

...more

View all episodes

By Paige Vandy

4.5

1414 ratings