REGISTER NOW: LIVE MASTERCLASS → https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

In this episode, Paige answers your biggest membership questions in this month’s Q&A — covering how to sign mid-ticket members without sales calls, whether content or community matters more, how to transition from 1:1 without losing income, and whether a $20 membership can actually scale to five figures.

FREE On Demand 35 Minute Training: The 4 Part System to Launch & Scale a 7 Figure Online Membership (even from zero) :

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club Here:

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

If you’re trying to grow your membership but feel stuck between “I need more visibility” and “I need better retention”… this episode will help you diagnose exactly where to focus.

Paige breaks down how to build a funnel that replaces sales calls, how to think about retention vs visibility, and what it actually takes to scale sustainably without burning yourself out.

You’ll discover:

🏴 How to sign mid-ticket members consistently without sales calls (and what your funnel must do instead)

🏴 The 5-step decision framework your funnel needs to diagnose, prescribe, contrast outcomes, and create urgency

🏴 Why you cannot rely on “just having a membership” to sell — and why strategic sales events make everything easier

🏴 What’s more important for long-term wealth: content or community (and why retention is where real money is built)

🏴 The churn benchmarks you need to know (what’s normal, what’s elite, and when you have a leak)

🏴 Where to focus first if you want to hit your first six-figure year

🏴 How to transition from fully booked 1:1 to a membership model without blowing up your stability

🏴 Whether a $20 membership can realistically scale to five figures — and what would actually be required

If you’ve been wondering where to focus, what to fix, or how to sell without getting on sales calls all day — this episode gives you the clarity.

Have questions you want answered on the show??

Submit your questions to our email at [email protected] for our end of month Q+A episode.

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership? Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to start and scale your online membership site

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Want higher touch support growing your membership this year??

Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures 🏴

Apply for 1:1 Membership Consulting Here:

https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

Youtube: @themembershipmuse

Tik Tok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

🏴 FREE LIVE MASTERCLASS: https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

🏴 Join Million Dollar Memberships Club Here: https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

In this episode, Paige breaks down exactly when you should include a course inside your membership… and when it’s actually a mistake.

If you’ve been overthinking whether your membership needs a full curriculum, tons of modules, or a massive content vault to feel “valuable enough,” this episode will simplify everything.

Most founders assume more content equals more value. But that belief can quietly hurt your retention, overwhelm your members, and create unnecessary pressure for you as the founder.

Paige walks you through how to think about structure the right way, how to decide if your transformation requires a roadmap, and how to build a membership people actually stay in month after month.

You’ll discover:

🏴 The real difference between a course and a true membership model

🏴 When a structured roadmap increases clarity instead of overwhelm

🏴 Why turning your membership into a content vault can decrease retention

🏴 The biggest mistake founders make when adding modules “just in case”

🏴 How to decide if your membership needs a core curriculum or ongoing live support

🏴 The hybrid structure Paige recommends for long-term retention and recurring revenue

If you’re building your membership right now and questioning whether it’s “big enough” or structured correctly, this episode will give you the clarity and confidence to move forward without overbuilding.

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

Ready to start or grow your membership? Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to start and scale your online membership site

Want higher touch support growing your membership this year?? Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures 📩 Apply for 1:1 Membership Consulting Here: https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564

Connect With Paige:

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build profitable memberships and escape the 1:1 hustle.

You’ll learn proven strategies to:

Launch and grow your membership faster

Keep members engaged and paying month after month

Turn your membership into a reliable, recurring revenue machine

If you love shows like:

You’ll feel right at home here.

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

FREE MASTERCLASS: BUILD A STICKY AF MEMBERSHIP COMMUNITY

🏴 Register here: https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

FREE On Demand 35 Minute Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Online Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club here:

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

In this episode, Paige breaks down the 7 core membership sales rules you need to understand if your goal is to hit your first million in membership sales.

This episode pulls back the curtain on what actually moves the needle when it comes to selling memberships, not hype, not posting more, not selling harder, but building the right systems and decision points.

If you want predictable membership sales without burning yourself out, this episode is required listening.

You’ll discover:

🏴 Why visibility is oxygen to your membership and how to become the go-to resource in your niche

🏴 Why urgency is required for action, and how to create it without pressure or sleazy tactics

🏴 Why live experiences outperform sales pages, emails, and DMs when it comes to selling memberships

🏴 What people actually mean when they say “I woke up to $10K in sales” and the automated sales engines behind it

🏴 How to design launches so your membership feels like the next obvious step, not a leap of faith

🏴 Why selling the outcome matters more than selling access, calls, or features

🏴 How to simplify your sales strategy so you sell less often, but more intentionally

If you feel like you’re constantly selling but not seeing consistent results, this episode will show you exactly what needs to change.

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club for step-by-step strategies to build recurring revenue without burnout

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Want higher touch support growing your membership this year??

Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures

📩 Apply here:

https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

FREE Live Membership Masterclass

How to Build a Sticky AF Membership Community (Feb 5, 2026)

👉 Register here: https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

If you’re listening before February 5, 2026, you still have time to join me live for this completely free training where I’ll walk you through:

🏴 The #1 mistake that’s killing your membership engagement

🏴 How to stop members from cancelling so you can stack recurring revenue monthly

🏴 How to get members talking, engaging, and posting without relying on you

Join us live for free, with the option to purchase the lifetime replay at registration.

In this episode of the Million Dollar Memberships Podcast, Paige breaks down one of the most common questions membership founders ask:

Should you keep your membership open year-round, or should you open and close it to create urgency and exclusivity?

This episode dives into the real differences between evergreen memberships and open/close memberships, the pros and cons of each, and which model actually supports faster growth, higher conversions, and healthier retention for most founders.

Paige shares her honest recommendations based on what she’s seen work inside Million Dollar Memberships Club, especially for founders trying to scale from zero to multi-six and seven figures.

You’ll discover:

🏴 The key differences between evergreen and open/close memberships

🏴 Why evergreen memberships often struggle with urgency and conversions

🏴 How open/close memberships create momentum, focus, and higher sign-ups

🏴 When evergreen actually makes sense (and when it doesn’t)

🏴 Why open/close can improve churn and prevent members from cancelling and rejoining

🏴 What to do if you want consistent sales without launching nonstop

Paige also explains why most founders want to choose evergreen, and the hard truth about why urgency is often the missing piece preventing memberships from growing faster.

If you’re deciding which model to use, or wondering if you chose the wrong one, this episode will give you clarity and a clear direction forward.

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to build, grow, and scale your online membership community

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Want higher touch support growing your membership this year??

Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures

📩 Apply here: https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy, and The Art of Online Business, you’ll feel right at home here. 🖤

🏴 NEW LIVE MASTERCLASS DATE: Feb 5th, 2026

Build a Sticky AF Membership Community, REGISTER FOR FREE BELOW:

https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

In this episode, Paige answers some of the most common questions membership founders ask about engagement, retention, feedback, and starting a membership from scratch.

If you’ve ever worried that your membership isn’t working because members aren’t posting or engaging publicly, this episode will completely reframe how you measure success inside your community.

FREE On-Demand 35-Minute Training:

🏴 The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club:

🏴 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

 You’ll learn:

• Whether it’s actually a problem if members are only consuming content

• What “normal” engagement looks like inside healthy memberships (10–20% active is standard)

• Why most members are quiet consumers — and why that’s not a red flag

• How engagement shifts as members gain confidence and start executing

• What matters more for retention than comments and postsPaige also covers:

How to keep members active in your community

• Encouraging member-to-member conversations

• Bringing members together through shared experiences

• Modeling the behavior you want to see

• Using leaders and ambassadors to set the tone

The best way to get feedback from members

• Why quarterly feedback surveys work best

• Why anonymous polls get more honest responses

• How to encourage participation without pressure

Can you start a membership with no previous clients?

• Why specificity matters even more when starting from zero

• How to define a clear before → after transition

• Why showing how results happen matters more than social proof early on

More From The Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training:

🏴 The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

🏴 Join Million Dollar Memberships Club

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Want higher-touch support growing your membership this year??

🏴 Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures

https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

🏴 NEW LIVE MASTERCLASS DATE: Feb 5th, 2026

Build a Sticky AF Membership Community, REGISTER FOR FREE BELOW:

https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

🏴 Join Million Dollar Memberships Club

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

In this episode, Paige breaks down the absolute non-negotiable focus points every membership founder must prioritize in their first year if they want to build a community that actually scales.

If you’re in year one of your membership — or even if you’re past year one — this episode is a must-listen to make sure you haven’t skipped the foundations that drive long-term growth, retention, and momentum.

Because here’s the truth: memberships don’t scale because of more content — they scale because of culture, clarity, and community.

Paige walks you through the exact areas she sees founders overlook the most… and why skipping these basics is often the reason memberships stall, churn stays high, or the business starts to feel heavy instead of sustainable.

You’ll discover:

✔️ Why community building must come before content — and how member-to-member connection is what actually keeps people paying

✔️ How to start lean without under-delivering (and why adding too much too soon hurts growth)

✔️ What a clear success path really looks like — and why confusion is the fastest way to lose members

✔️ Why founder-led presence matters so much in year one (and when to bring in support later)

✔️ The importance of a consistent weekly cadence members can rely on — even if it feels “boring” to you

✔️ Why retention must be a priority from day one, not something you fix later

✔️ How member celebration and recognition directly impacts engagement, culture, and longevity

At the end of the day, every single one of these non-negotiables comes down to two things:

Building culture.

And setting your members up for success.

If you want a membership that lasts — not one that fizzles out after the honeymoon phase — this episode lays the foundation.

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

🏴 https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to build a scalable, sticky community that drives recurring revenue.

🏴 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Want higher touch support growing your membership this year??

Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures 📩

Apply for 1:1 Membership Consulting here:

🏴 https://paigevandy.mykajabi.com/expand-community-business-consulting-2024?preview_theme_id=2159387564

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy by Amy Porterfield, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy by Lori Harder, and The Art of Online Business by Rick Mulready — you’ll feel right at home here 🖤

FREE MASTERCLASS: BUILD A STICKY AF MEMBERSHIP COMMUNITY

🏴 Register here: https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community#/

In this episode, Paige breaks down the single most overlooked focus that separates struggling memberships from 7-figure, long-term communities — and spoiler: it has nothing to do with getting more sign-ups.

Most membership founders spend their time chasing new members or pumping out endless content… while completely ignoring the one thing that actually determines whether a membership grows, plateaus, or quietly crumbles.

This episode is a must-listen if your members are joining but not engaging, if your community feels quiet unless you’re pushing every conversation, or if your revenue feels like a leaky bucket no matter how often you sell.

You’ll also hear all the details about Paige’s FREE live masterclass happening January 13th, where she’s teaching exactly how to build a sticky, high-retention membership community that scales.

You’ll discover:

The real reason memberships fail (and why it’s rarely your offer or content)

Why 70% of your membership revenue comes from retention, not new sign-ups

The difference between building an audience vs. building a true community

Why content alone will never keep members paying long-term

How to stop being the “glue” holding your membership together

What actually makes members stay, engage, and talk about your membership everywhere

More From Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Online Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and build a scalable, high-retention community that actually lasts

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Want higher touch support growing your membership this year??

Work with Paige 1:1 to scale to 7 or multi-7 figures

📩 Apply for 1:1 Membership Consulting Here

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy by Amy Porterfield, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy by Lori Harder, and The Art of Online Business by Rick Mulready — you’ll feel right at home here 🖤

✨ FREE LIVE MASTERCLASS: How to Build a Sticky AF Membership Community

Only 200 spots available — join now before seats sell out.

🏴 https://paigevandy.com/live-masterclass-sticky-community

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to build a profitable, sticky membership community.

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

In this episode, Paige breaks down the three most common reasons members cancel — and why even great memberships quietly lose people if these areas are overlooked.

This episode is the perfect precursor to her free live masterclass, where she’s teaching you exactly how to build a sticky AF membership community — the kind that feels like home, gets members real results, and keeps them staying long-term.

If you’ve ever felt like:

Your membership feels quiet or disconnected

You’re constantly the one prompting engagement

Members join… then disappear

You’re stuck at a member plateau

Or you’re relying on launches to replace churn

This episode (and the masterclass) are for you.

You’ll discover:

The #1 reason members cancel even when your content is good

Why connection matters more than content inside a membership

How lack of clarity around results causes silent cancellations

The hidden danger of overwhelming members with too much content

Why organization, navigation, and simplicity directly impact retention

How to stop being the “glue” holding your membership together

Paige also shares a powerful real-life analogy that will completely shift how you think about community building — and a personal story about joining a membership that should have worked… but didn’t.

Free Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to build a profitable, sticky membership community.

https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Already have a membership and want to scale?

Work with Paige 1:1 — email [email protected]

Connect With Paige

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build profitable memberships, increase retention, and escape the one-on-one hustle.

You’ll learn how to:

Build a membership people actually want to stay in

Create culture, connection, and community that sells itself

Turn your membership into reliable, recurring revenue

If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy, or The Art of Online Business, you’ll feel right at home here. 🖤

FREE On-Demand 35-Minute Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership (Even From Zero)

👉 https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club here:

👉 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

In this Membership Q+A episode, Paige answers some of the most common (and most misunderstood) questions membership founders are asking right now — from whether a membership needs to be your only offer, to how to move people from free to paid, to whether guest experts are actually helping or hurting your membership growth.

If you’ve been overthinking your membership structure, second-guessing your audience size, or feeling stuck trying to “do it the right way,” this episode will bring clarity fast.

Paige breaks down what actually matters when building a profitable, sustainable membership — and what founders waste way too much time worrying about.

You’ll discover:

✔️ Whether a membership has to be your only offer — and the real question you should be asking instead

✔️ Why focusing on one core offer often leads to faster growth and less burnout

✔️ How to move people from free to paid using incubator-style sales events (without selling every week)

✔️ What you actually need to convert free members into paid ones (visibility, reason, urgency)

✔️ Whether you need a big email list or large audience before launching a membership

✔️ Why “done is better than perfect” — and how founding members help you build a better membership faster

✔️ When guest experts help retention — and when they dilute your positioning

✔️ Why membership niches don’t fail… unclear transformations do

If you’re trying to build a membership that creates real momentum, delivers consistent results, and supports the life you actually want — this episode will help you simplify your strategy and focus on what moves the needle.

More From The Million Dollar Memberships Podcast:

Free Training:

The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

👉 https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step strategies to build, grow, and scale your online membership community with confidence.

👉 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

Already have a successful membership and want to scale?

Work with Paige 1:1 → Email [email protected]

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

TikTok: @membershipmuseofficial

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build highly successful online membership communities and scale to multiple 6 and 7 figures on autopilot.

If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy by Amy Porterfield, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy by Lori Harder, and The Art of Online Business by Rick Mulready — you’ll feel right at home here. 🤍

FREE On-Demand 35 Minute Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Online Membership

👉 https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step guidance on building, launching, and scaling a profitable membership — without burnout.

👉 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

In this episode, Paige breaks down 10 foundational rules every membership founder needs to live by if they want to grow a profitable, sustainable membership without feeling overwhelmed, scattered, or chained to their laptop.

This is a more relaxed, end-of-year, easy-listening episode — perfect for a road trip, a cozy planning day, or a quiet reset moment — but don’t mistake that for fluff. These rules are the non-negotiables behind memberships that last, scale, and actually support your life.

If you’re heading into the new year wanting your membership to finally feel clear, grounded, and momentum-driven, this episode will help you refocus on what actually matters.

You’ll discover:

Why member-to-member connection is the true growth engine behind every successful membership

Why more content ≠ more value, and what actually creates results for your members

Why getting narrow and staying narrow is essential in today’s oversaturated market

How making your members the main character radically improves culture and retention

Why building for sustainability (not performance) protects your future self

The truth about retention being the real revenue driver inside memberships

How and when to buy back your time so you can stay in the visionary seat

How to take member feedback seriously without letting it derail your entire model

Why visibility is literal oxygen for your membership (even if you hate posting)

Why memberships compound over time, and why staying the course changes everything

If you’re coming from 1:1 work and feeling impatient with the slower build of a membership — or questioning whether it’s “working” yet — this episode will bring you back to reality, clarity, and long-term thinking.

🎓 Free Training: The 4-Part System to Launch & Scale a 6 & 7 Figure Membership

https://paigevandy.com/masterclass-opt-in

💬 Ready to start or grow your membership?

Join Million Dollar Memberships Club and get step-by-step guidance on building, launching, and scaling a profitable membership — without burnout.

👉 https://paigevandy.com/million-dollar-memberships-club

💼 Already running a successful membership and want to scale?

Work with Paige 1:1 → Email [email protected]

Connect With Paige:

Instagram: @themembershipmuse

YouTube: @themembershipmuse

This podcast is for coaches, service providers, and online entrepreneurs who want to build profitable memberships, escape the 1:1 grind, and create recurring revenue without sacrificing their life.

You’ll learn proven strategies to:

Grow your membership sustainably

Improve retention and community culture

Build a membership that compounds month after month

If you love shows like Online Marketing Made Easy, Membership Geeks, Earn Your Happy, and The Art of Online Business, you’ll feel right at home here.