Latter Day Struggles

407: Is the Family Proclamation a Commentary or a Revelation?


Listen Later

Send us a Positive Review!

Series Title:  What does the Family Proclamation Mean to You? [Episode I of II]


Welcome to this two-part series where Valerie welcomes returned guest scholar Taylor Petrey to discuss the LDS Church's Family Proclamation to the World as it reaches its 30th anniversary.

The heart of the episode centers on Taylor's controversial Salt Lake Tribune opinion piece in September 2025 (linked below) arguing that The Family Proclamation should be understood as commentary rather than revelation or unchanging doctrine. This characterization sparked significant pushback from conservative church members who insisted the document represents eternal, unchanging truth. 

Taylor and Valerie explore the complex and often inconsistent ways that the LDS Church uses terms like doctrine, revelation, policy, and commentary, noting how these categories shift depending on context and speaker. They discuss how the proclamation itself has been reinterpreted over time and set you up for the second part of their conversation where they dive deeply into the changing interpretations themselves. 


The Family Proclamation

Op Ed by Taylor Petrey


Timestamps:

00:00 Introduction and Guest Welcome

00:11 Discussing the Family Proclamation

01:48 Cultural and Political Context

04:20 Historical Background of Family Proclamations

07:04 The 1995 Proclamation and Its Impact

13:21 Opinion Piece and Public Reaction

24:43 Controversy and Clarifications

27:57 Historical Changes in Church Teachings

28:33 Modern Reinterpretations of Doctrine

30:42 Balancing Eternal Truths and Continuing Revelation

32:58 The Controversy of Words and Authority

36:15 Revelation vs. Policy: A Case Study

38:10 The Fluidity of Revelation

43:45 The Role of Commentary in Church Doctrine

48:20 Setting Up for the Next Episode

51:36 Final Thoughts and Conclusion

Support the show

Support the show

Listen, Share, Rate & Review EPISODES

Friday Episodes Annual Access $89

Friday Episodes Monthly Access $10

Valerie’s Support & Processing Groups

Gift a Scholarship

Download Free Resources

Visit our Website

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Latter Day StrugglesBy Valerie Hamaker

  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5

4.5

845 ratings


More shows like Latter Day Struggles

View all
RadioWest by KUER

RadioWest

780 Listeners

Mormon Stories Podcast by Dr. John Dehlin

Mormon Stories Podcast

5,559 Listeners

Better Than Happy by Jody Moore

Better Than Happy

5,680 Listeners

Leading Saints Podcast by Leading Saints

Leading Saints Podcast

1,231 Listeners

Mormon Land by The Salt Lake Tribune

Mormon Land

339 Listeners

Faith Matters by Faith Matters Foundation

Faith Matters

1,775 Listeners

Radio Free Mormon by Mormon Discussion Inc

Radio Free Mormon

1,331 Listeners

All In by LDS Living

All In

6,437 Listeners

Conversations with Dr. Jennifer by Dr. Jennifer Finlayson-Fife

Conversations with Dr. Jennifer

1,067 Listeners

Don't Miss This Study by Emily Freeman & David Butler

Don't Miss This Study

3,708 Listeners

At Last She Said It by Cynthia Winward, Susan Hinckley

At Last She Said It

1,040 Listeners

followHIM by Hank Smith & John Bytheway

followHIM

10,999 Listeners

Ask Dr. Julie Hanks by Dr. Julie Hanks

Ask Dr. Julie Hanks

744 Listeners

Come Back Podcast by Ashly Stone

Come Back Podcast

1,592 Listeners

Girlscamp by Hayley Rawle

Girlscamp

1,885 Listeners