Analysis

Analysis

By BBC Radio 4NewsPolitics
Download on the App Store

Analysis episodes

  • Roberto Unger

    Renowned social theorist Roberto Unger believes that left-of-centre progressives - his own political side - lack the imagination required to tackle the fundamental problems of society. In the run-up to the US presidential elections of 2012, he declared that his former student Barack Obama "must be defeated". Professor Unger argued that President Obama had failed in his first term in office to advance the progressive cause. There was, Unger maintained, effectively no difference between the Democrat and Republican political programmes.

    In front of an audience at the London School of Economics and Political Science, Roberto Unger discusses with presenter Jo Fidgen the reasons for his critical appraisal of the progressive left in the United States and Europe. He sets out what he believes its alternative agenda should be and gives his verdict on another of his former students: Ed Miliband.

    Roberto Mangabeira Unger is the Roscoe Pound professor at Harvard Law School. He served as a minister in the Brazilian government of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva from 2007-2009. His books include: "The Left Alternative"; "Democracy Realised"; and "The Self Awakened". His new book, published next year, will address a new theme: "The Religion of the Future".

    #LSEProgressive

    Producer: Simon Coates.

    29 min
  • France: Sinking Slowly?

    The French are far more attached to the idea of a centralised, big state than their Anglo-Saxon counterparts. The philosophy behind it, Colbertism, holds that the economy of France should serve the state and that the state should direct the economy.

    But as France's big state looks less affordable, some French intellectuals are arguing that it is time that French identity became less tied to the dirigiste idea. Former BBC Paris Correspondent Emma Jane Kirby travels to France to meet those questioning their country's traditional resistance to economic reform.

    Producer: Fiona Leach.

    29 min
  • Importing the Metropolitan Revolution

    In America, there is talk of a "metropolitan revolution" as big cities reinvent themselves. Matthew Taylor asks if Britain too can transform its economy by setting city halls free.

    In America, there's a growing realisation that the old economic model, based on every city aiming for "a Starbucks, stadia and stealing business," has failed to revive urban economies. But now cities such as Denver, Colorado -- once famous for the oil money that inspired the soap opera Dynasty -- have turned a corner. This "Metropolitan Revolution" was led by local mayors who ripped up the old administrative boundaries and did creative things to diversify the economy and create jobs, such as building a vast new airports and offering incentives to hi-tech start-ups.

    For this week's edition of Analysis, Matthew Taylor, chief executive of the RSA and a former insider in Downing Street under Tony Blair, sets out to see if these new ideas could hold answers for Britain's long term economic future. Cities are where the modern global economy happens, but ever since the decline of heavy industry, Britain's northern cities have performed below the national average. Now, key national and local figures, from Lord Michael Heseltine to Bristol's new Mayor George Ferguson, famous for his red trousers, are pinning their hopes for an economic revival on giving greater economic powers to city halls.

    Speaking to a wide range of voices from both sides of the Atlantic, and combining wit with insights from urban geography, history and economics, Matthew asks: could Britain's great cities be the key to us all turning the economic corner?

    Producer: Mukul Devichand.

    29 min
  • Syria: Inside the Opposition

    Syria's opposition movements comprise a diverse range of political and armed groups. But how do they differ in terms of their ideology, their modus operandi and in their vision for a post-conflict Syria?

    Edward Stourton investigates the numerous alternatives to President Assad and assesses which groups are gaining or losing influence on the ground after more than two years of bloody fighting.

    The programme will hear from those in charge of the National Coalition - the Istanbul based group officially recognised by the UK government but dismissed by some as "the opposition of the hotels".

    Ahead of the United Nations Geneva II negotiations, expected in late November, Edward Stourton will examine why, in a country with an overwhelming Sunni Muslim majority, a leader from the small Alawi minority community has managed to hang on to power.

    Contributions from:

    Monzer Akbik, Chief of Staff to the President of the National Coalition;
    Walid Saffour, former Muslim Brotherhood activist and Coalition Representative to the UK;
    Sheikh Mohammed Yaqoubi, Syrian Sunni scholar;
    Raphael Lefevre, author of Ashes of Hama: The Muslim Brotherhood in Syria;
    Aron Lund, Middle East analyst;
    Faisal Irshaid, BBC Monitoring.

    Producer: Hannah Barnes.

    29 min
  • Quantitative Easing: Miracle Cure or Dangerous Addiction?

    Quantitative Easing was the drug prescribed by economists to keep Western economies functioning in a moment of crisis. Sunday Telegraph economic commentator Liam Halligan argues that the policy of money creation has now become a dangerous addiction.

    Interviewees include:

    Dr Adam Posen, President of the Petersen Institute for International Economics in Washington DC

    Stephen King, Chief Economist of HSBC
    Jim Rickards, author of Currency Wars
    Professor Richard Werner, Chair in International Banking at Southampton University
    Dan Conaghan, author of The Bank: Inside the Bank of England
    Dr Philippa Malmgren, former financial markets advisor to the US President

    Producer: Phil Kemp.

    29 min
  • What Are Charities For?

    Charities have been drawn into the world of outsourced service provision, with the state as their biggest customer and payment made on a results basis. It is a trend which is set to accelerate with government plans to hand over to charities much of the work currently done by the public sector.

    But has the target driven world of providing such services as welfare to work support and rehabilitating offenders destroyed something of the traditional philanthropic nature of charities? Fran Abrams investigates.

    Producer: Mukul Devichand.

    29 min
  • Edward Snowden: Leaker, Saviour, Traitor, Spy?

    Last June, Edward Snowden, a man still in his twenties with, as he put it, "a home in paradise", went on the run. He took with him vast amounts of secret information belonging to the US government's security services.

    Snowden holds libertarian - or anti-statist - views. He believes the American government's pervasive surveillance activities which he revealed break the law but are also morally wrong.

    In Britain, "The Guardian" newspaper published the classified information Snowden had obtained. This seemed odd. Editorially, it was not sympathetic to Snowden's anti-state nostrums. But, on privacy grounds, it agreed with him that it was inherently wrong for democratic governments to spy on their citizens online. Furthermore, it argued that governments should not decide for themselves when and how they would do their surveillance.

    It is this political alliance between the libertarian right and the liberal left - which are normally opposed to one another - which David Aaronovitch investigates in this programme.

    He explores, in a detailed interview with the editor of "The Guardian", Alan Rusbridger, why the newspaper published the secret information. Are states threatening citizens' privacy in the cyber age? Or is it in fact governments which are more vulnerable than ever before to the unauthorised disclosure of their secrets?

    What secrets is the state itself entitled to keep from its citizens and from potential enemies? And who decides that question?the security services, Parliament or the government? Or the press and the whistle-blowers? Alan Rusbridger claims his newspaper can properly adjudicate what should and should not be published about state secrets. But how does he justify that apparently self-serving argument?

    29 min
  • Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood: Why Did They Fail?

    Barely a year after Egypt's post-revolution elections were held, millions of protestors took to the streets to demand the resignation of President Mohammed Morsi. After a short stand-off with army leaders, he was removed from power in what many describe as a coup d'etat.

    The subsequent clashes between Mr Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood supporters and security forces have proved violent and bloody and the country is once again being governed by the military - but what were the events which closed this short chapter in the fledgling Egyptian democracy?

    Christopher de Bellaigue speaks to insiders from across Egypt's political spectrum to reveal the mistakes and power-plays which led to the downfall of the country's first democratically elected president.

    Contributors:

    Dr Abdul Mawgoud Dardery, former Freedom and Justice Party MP for Luxor.

    Dr Hisham Hellyer, associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute (London) and the Brookings Institution (Washington).

    Dr Omar Ashour, senior lecturer in Middle East Politics and Security Studies, University of Exeter.

    Angy Ghannam, Head of BBC Monitoring, Cairo.

    Dr Wael Haddara, former communications adviser to President Mohammed Morsi.

    Dr Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh, founder of the Strong Egypt party.

    Producer: Richard Fenton-Smith

    Editor: Innes Bowen

    29 min
  • The Rule of Law v the Rule of Man

    With huge concern over tax avoidance, tax officials are the latest to be given increased powers of discretion. They will be able to penalise people who have obeyed the letter of the law, but who have contravened the spirit of the tax code - as determined by the officials themselves, based on certain criteria. The use of official discretion is now applying across the UK's legal systems, from areas such as tax and finance to crime and hate speech.

    Philosopher Jamie Whyte asks: is this growth in the Rule of Man undermining the Rule of Law? If officials can punish you, despite the fact that you followed the rules on the books, doesn't that raise the danger of injustice?

    Even though few tears are being shed for tax avoiders, couldn't the lack of legal clarity lead to uncertainty? Would that drive business away from Britain? Jamie unravels the methods of sophisticated tax lawyers, and speaks to academic thinkers and legislators. He asks if we are we creating a culture where it pays to cosy up to officials. And he explores the deeper philosophy of the Rule of Law and whether it is being diminished in our uncertain times.

    Producer: Mukul Devichand.

    28 min

About Analysis

From the publisher's feed

Programme examining the ideas and forces which shape public policy in Britain and abroad, presented by distinguished writers, journalists and academics.

More shows like Analysis

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,618 Listeners

From Our Own Correspondent by BBC Radio 4

From Our Own Correspondent

371 Listeners

More or Less by BBC Radio 4

More or Less

873 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,050 Listeners

The Reith Lectures by BBC Radio 4

The Reith Lectures

156 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,485 Listeners

The Documentary Podcast by BBC World Service

The Documentary Podcast

1,795 Listeners

In Our Time: History by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time: History

1,883 Listeners

6 Minute English by BBC Radio

6 Minute English

1,825 Listeners

Learning English Conversations by BBC Radio

Learning English Conversations

1,037 Listeners

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4 by BBC Radio 4

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4

2,112 Listeners

The Infinite Monkey Cage by BBC Radio 4

The Infinite Monkey Cage

1,907 Listeners

Profile by BBC Radio 4

Profile

106 Listeners

The Media Show by BBC Radio 4

The Media Show

34 Listeners

BBC Inside Science by BBC Radio 4

BBC Inside Science

394 Listeners

Moral Maze by BBC Radio 4

Moral Maze

69 Listeners

The Inquiry by BBC World Service

The Inquiry

727 Listeners

Start the Week by BBC Radio 4

Start the Week

161 Listeners

Any Questions? and Any Answers? by BBC Radio 4

Any Questions? and Any Answers?

43 Listeners

The Politics Show by The New Statesman

The Politics Show

124 Listeners

The Briefing Room by BBC Radio 4

The Briefing Room

59 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,219 Listeners

The Bomb by BBC World Service

The Bomb

1,004 Listeners

Westminster Insider by POLITICO

Westminster Insider

32 Listeners

Radical by BBC Radio 4

Radical

30 Listeners