The Bullvine

E307 The $50 Billion Truth: Why Canada’s Supply Management System is Quietly Outperforming Every ‘Free Market’ Dairy System


Listen Later

In this explosive episode, we dive deep into the most controversial analysis in dairy policy today. While economists worship at the altar of free markets, we expose the shocking reality: Canada's supply management system is quietly outperforming every single "free market" dairy system on the planet. From 55% bankruptcy spikes in the U.S. to Australian farmers earning $2.46 per hour, we reveal why the "free market" emperor has no clothes—and why stability might be the most radical choice you can make.

Key Topics Covered

Opening Segment: The Free Market Fiction

  • The $33 billion bailout reality: How U.S. "free markets" actually depend on massive taxpayer subsidies
  • Chapter 12 bankruptcy surge: 55% increase in U.S. farm failures in 2024
  • The Australian catastrophe: 55% of producers considering industry exit

Core Analysis: Canada vs. The World

  • Financial stability metrics: 0.191 debt-to-equity ratio vs. New Zealand's 47.4%
  • Production efficiency: 10,400 kg per cow yields matching Denmark's world-class output
  • Technology adoption: 17% robotic milking penetration under stable pricing systems

Hidden Costs Exposed

  • The subsidy shell game: $0.20-$0.29 per liter in hidden taxpayer costs for "cheap" U.S. milk
  • Environmental externalities: Canada's 0.94 kg CO2-equivalent per liter vs. 2.5 kg global average
  • Social destruction: 80% farm loss in Australia since 1980

Implementation Framework

  • ROI analysis: 7-10 year payback periods vs. 15+ years under volatile systems
  • Strategic planning: Policy roadmap for system reform
  • Operation assessment: Tools for evaluating your farm's vulnerability

Key Statistics & Data Points

  • $33.1 billion: U.S. government farm payments projected for 2025
  • 55%: Increase in U.S. Chapter 12 farm bankruptcies in 2024
  • 96 vs. 357: Average herd size in Canada vs. U.S. (cows per farm)
  • 0.191 vs. 47.4%: Debt ratios comparing Canadian stability to New Zealand leverage
  • 10,400 kg: Canadian milk yield per cow matching world-class Danish output
  • 17%: Canadian dairy cows milked by robotic systems
  • $200,000-300,000: Robotic milking system investment with predictable returns

Read the full article here - https://www.thebullvine.com/dairy-industry/the-50-billion-truth-why-canadas-supply-management-system-is-quietly-outperforming-every-free-market-dairy-system/

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The BullvineBy The Bullvine

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

3 ratings


More shows like The Bullvine

View all
Working Cows - Regenerative Ranching to Maximize Profitability and Soil Health by Clay Conry

Working Cows - Regenerative Ranching to Maximize Profitability and Soil Health

430 Listeners

The Business of Agriculture Podcast by Damian Mason

The Business of Agriculture Podcast

121 Listeners

Farm4Profit Podcast by David Whitaker, Corey Hillebo, Tanner Winterhof

Farm4Profit Podcast

385 Listeners

DairyVoice Podcast by DairyBusiness

DairyVoice Podcast

19 Listeners

Progressive Dairy Podcast by Progressive Dairy editors

Progressive Dairy Podcast

20 Listeners

Grain Markets and Other Stuff by Joe Vaclavik

Grain Markets and Other Stuff

342 Listeners

Beyond The Ring by Beyond The Ring

Beyond The Ring

778 Listeners

Ranching Returns Podcast by Jared Luhman

Ranching Returns Podcast

224 Listeners

Barn Talk by Tork and Sawyer Whisler

Barn Talk

1,655 Listeners

Angus Underground by David Brown

Angus Underground

204 Listeners

Uplevel Dairy Podcast by Peggy Coffeen

Uplevel Dairy Podcast

35 Listeners

The Loonie Hour by Steve Saretsky

The Loonie Hour

13 Listeners

The Semex Podcast by Semex

The Semex Podcast

9 Listeners

STtalks by STgenetics

STtalks

10 Listeners

The Select Sires Podcast by Select Sires

The Select Sires Podcast

11 Listeners