Being a workplace mediator and mediation trainer, Julie Hutchison brings us a wealth of experience. She has seen it all, from minor office spats to full-blown conflicts. Her insights into dealing with toxic employees are invaluable for anyone looking to maintain a harmonious and productive workplace. 

We started by defining what we mean by toxic employees. According to Julie Hutchison, the term “toxic” might be a bit harsh, but it’s widely understood. Toxic employees are those who drain energy, sow discord, and generally make like difficult for their colleagues. They might be resistant to change, habitually negative, or outright confrontational. The impact of such behaviour can be devastating, affecting team morale, productivity, and ultimately, the profitability of the business. 

Julie Hutchison emphasised the importance of addressing these issues head-on. Avoidance, she noted, only leads to more significant problems down the line. As leaders, it's our responsibility to tackle these situations with empathy and clarity. Julie advised using the BIN model – Behaviour, Impact, Need – as a framework for these tough conversations. This model helps to depersonalise the issue and focus on specific behaviours and their impacts, making it easier to articulate the need for change. 

We discussed the importance of understanding the underlying causes of toxic behaviour. Julie Hutchison pointed out that these employees might be reacting to unmet needs or external stressors. By taking the time to listen and understand, leaders can often uncover the root of the problem and address it more effectively. This empathetic approach can help turn a negative situation into a positive one, fostering loyalty and engagement rather than resentment. 

Julie Hutchison also highlighted the value of regular follow-ups. Once the initial conversation has taken place, it’s crucial to check in regularly to ensure progress is being made. This doesn't have to be a formal meeting every time – even a casual chat over coffee can be effective. The key is to maintain open lines of communication and provide ongoing support. 

One of the standout moments in our discussion was Julie’s emphasis on self-awareness for leaders. Toxic employees can sometimes be a mirror, reflecting issues within the leadership or the broader organisational culture. By examining our actions and responses, we can often find ways to improve the environment and reduce the likelihood of such behaviours arising in the first place. 

In summary, dealing with toxic employees is never easy, but it's an essential skill for any leader. Julie Hutchison’s advice to approach these situations with empathy, clarity, and a structured framework like the BIN model can make a significant difference. By understanding the root causes of toxic behaviour and maintaining regular follow-ups, we can foster a more positive and productive workplace. 

Remember, the goal is not just to eliminate toxic behaviour but to transform it. By investing time and effort into understanding and addressing these issues, we can turn a potentially negative situation into an opportunity for growth and improvement. If you ever find yourself facing a toxic employee, take a step back, breathe, and remember Julie Hutchison's insights from this episode. 

Connect on LinkedIn HERE with Ian and also with Stuart by clicking this LINK 

And when you’re ready to take the next step in growing your MSP, come and take the Scale with Confidence MSP Mastery Quiz. In just three minutes, you’ll get a 360-degree scan of your MSP and identify the one or two tactics that could help you find more time, engage & align your people and generate more leads. 

OR  

To join our amazing Facebook Group of over 400 MSPs where we are helping you Scale Up with Confidence, then click HERE 

Until next time, look after yourself and I’ll catch up with you soon!