On Brand with Nick Westergaard

Finding the Right Agency Partner


Listen Later

The secret to great creative work isn’t just the idea — it’s knowing how to get there. Toby Wilkinson, co-founder of Ask Us For Ideas, has spent the last decade helping brands navigate the messy world of agencies, briefs, and creative partnerships to make the process smoother, smarter, and more successful.


What You'll Learn

  • Why choosing the right agency is just as important as the creative work itself
  • How to align your team internally before starting the agency selection process
  • The “head and heart” test for evaluating agency fit
  • Common red flags and relationship pitfalls to watch for
  • How to leverage agency networks and insights to make smarter selections
  • Episode Chapters

    (00:00) Intro

    (00:30) Welcome Toby Wilkinson

    (01:10) The story behind Ask Us For Ideas

    (04:18) Defining the perfect agency fit

    (08:40) The agency selection process step by step

    (12:07) Red flags in agency relationships

    (17:25) Navigating a shifting agency landscape

    (21:17) Favorite success stories and brands that inspire

    Toby Wilkinson is the co-founder of Ask Us For Ideas (AUFI), a company dedicated to helping brands find the right creative partners. Over the last decade, he has connected more than 2,000 brands — from startups to global companies — with agencies across branding, marketing, digital, social, and more. He is passionate about creating productive, long-term partnerships between brands and agencies and shares his insights through AUFI’s website, podcast, and Substack.

    What Brand Has Made Toby Smile Recently? Toby has been enjoying the meal kit delivery company Mindful Chef. He appreciates the quality of the ingredients, the variety of meals, and the shared cooking experience it brings him and his wife, making it a meaningful part of his daily routine.


    Resources & Links

    • Connect with Toby on LinkedIn.
    • As discussed, check out the AUFI website, podcast, and Substack.
    • Support the Show

      • Watch or listen on Apple PodcastsSpotifyYouTube, Amazon/AudibleTuneIn, and iHeart.
      • Rate and review on Apple Podcasts and Spotify to help others find the show.
      • Share this episode email a friend or colleague this episode.
      • Sign up for my free Story Strategies newsletter for branding and storytelling tips.

        On Brand is a part of the Marketing Podcast Network.

        Until next week, I’ll see you on the Internet!

        Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

        ...more
        View all episodesView all episodes
        Download on the App Store

        On Brand with Nick WestergaardBy Nick Westergaard

        • 4.8
        • 4.8
        • 4.8
        • 4.8
        • 4.8

        4.8

        93 ratings


        More shows like On Brand with Nick Westergaard

        View all
        The Knowledge Project by Shane Parrish

        The Knowledge Project

        2,682 Listeners

        Daily Creative with Todd Henry by Todd Henry

        Daily Creative with Todd Henry

        516 Listeners

        Social Media Marketing Podcast by Michael Stelzner, Social Media Examiner

        Social Media Marketing Podcast

        1,442 Listeners

        The StoryBrand Podcast by StoryBrand.com

        The StoryBrand Podcast

        1,935 Listeners

        The Digital Marketing Podcast by Daniel Rowles and Ciaran Rogers

        The Digital Marketing Podcast

        114 Listeners

        Marketing School - Digital Marketing and Online Marketing Tips by Eric Siu and Neil Patel

        Marketing School - Digital Marketing and Online Marketing Tips

        1,263 Listeners

        10% Happier with Dan Harris by 10% Happier

        10% Happier with Dan Harris

        12,710 Listeners

        The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett by DOAC

        The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

        8,462 Listeners

        The Futur with Chris Do by The Futur

        The Futur with Chris Do

        857 Listeners

        Hello Monday with Jessi Hempel by LinkedIn

        Hello Monday with Jessi Hempel

        1,017 Listeners

        Nudge by Phill Agnew

        Nudge

        177 Listeners

        The CMO Podcast by vYve & Jim Stengel

        The CMO Podcast

        351 Listeners

        The Marketing Millennials by Daniel Murray

        The Marketing Millennials

        155 Listeners

        Marketing Against The Grain by Hubspot Media

        Marketing Against The Grain

        358 Listeners

        The CEO’s Guide to Marketing by Forbes

        The CEO’s Guide to Marketing

        25 Listeners