The First Home Guidebook

How to deal with Underquoting


Listen Later

In this episode, I unpack the murky (and often maddening) world of underquoting in Victoria—what it is, why it happens, and how you can protect yourself as a buyer. With over 13 years experience as a buyer’s agent, I’ve seen just how widespread and frustrating this issue is, and I’m breaking down not just the rules, but the real-world implications, examples, and strategies you need to know.

🔍 What I Cover:
  • What underquoting actually is (according to Consumer Affairs Victoria)
  • The 3 rules agents must follow when quoting a price
  • Why Statement of Information pricing isn't always trustworthy
  • Real examples of dodgy quoting practices
  • Why some agents are “technically” following the rules but still misleading buyers
  • How agents can use old or non-comparable sales to justify low quotes
  • The grey areas where the law is hard to enforce
  • What changes trigger a quote range update—and why that rarely happens
  • Why you shouldn't assume all agents (or quote ranges) are dodgy
  • Tips for decoding quote ranges before wasting time or money
  • The uncomfortable truth: underquoting works (and that’s why it persists)
  • The conflict agents face when trying to be ethical in an unethical environment

💡 Key Takeaways:

Underquoting is illegal, but hard to prove

✅ The Statement of Information can be manipulated—do your own comparable sales analysis

✅ If a vendor has rejected an offer based on price, the quote range must be updated

✅ If rejected based on terms, it doesn’t mean they have to update the quote range

✅ If the vendor won’t consider pre-auction offers, the agent isn’t required to pass yours on

Ask smart questions like:

“Can I confirm the top of the range would buy the property, assuming terms are acceptable?”🛠️ What You Can Do:

✅ DO:

  • Educate yourself on comparable sales
  • Learn what legislation agents must follow
  • Don’t be afraid to ask direct but polite pricing questions
  • Track what properties are selling for, not just what they're quoted at
  • Know your market and monitor sale trends

🚫 DON’T:

  • Assume all agents are doing the wrong thing (but don’t take them at face value either)
  • Start a fight with an agent during the negotiation phase—it can backfire
  • Waste money on building inspections without clarity on the vendor’s expectations

🧠 Final Thoughts:

There’s no perfect solution to underquoting. It’s an issue of compliance, competition, and at times—plain old bad behaviour. But as a buyer, you’re not powerless. Knowledge is your best defence.

And remember my motto:

Never let a bad agent, or a bad vendor, come between you and a good property.


🔗 Resources:
  • Consumer Affairs Victoria – Underquoting

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The First Home GuidebookBy Amy Lunardi


More shows like The First Home Guidebook

View all
The Hook Up by ABC Podcasts, triple j

The Hook Up

80 Listeners

Mamamia Out Loud by Mamamia Podcasts

Mamamia Out Loud

629 Listeners

The Economy, Stupid by ABC

The Economy, Stupid

26 Listeners

The Money Puzzle by The Australian

The Money Puzzle

46 Listeners

Ladies, We Need To Talk by ABC

Ladies, We Need To Talk

324 Listeners

Shameless by Shameless Media

Shameless

868 Listeners

money money money by Glen James

money money money

53 Listeners

The Elephant In The Room Property Podcast | Inside Australian Real Estate by Chris Bates

The Elephant In The Room Property Podcast | Inside Australian Real Estate

11 Listeners

She's On The Money by Victoria Devine

She's On The Money

145 Listeners

Life Uncut by Brittany Hockley and Laura Byrne

Life Uncut

289 Listeners

this is property by John Pidgeon & Rachelle Kroon

this is property

4 Listeners

The Broke Generation by Emma Edwards

The Broke Generation

33 Listeners

Two Broke Chicks by Alex Hourigan and Sally McMullen

Two Broke Chicks

30 Listeners

Get Rich Slow Club by Ana Kresina & Natasha Etschmann

Get Rich Slow Club

8 Listeners

Australian Property Podcast by Rask

Australian Property Podcast

6 Listeners