Anndrea Caruth, 39, a native of the island of St. Vincent, had worked hard to establish an early childhood center in her multifamily home in the Bronx, New York.  Anndrea had recently learned that she was expecting a baby with her fiancé when she suddenly vanished.  Her disappearance leaves family, friends, and neighbors baffled. Now, detectives are desperate to find the pregnant mom-to-be. What they uncovered  about Anndrea’s whereabouts would forever shock the community.

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/anndrea-caruth


Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlighting our podcast:
https://www.instagram.com/p/Cp88TlNOD3F/?igshid=Mzc1MmZhNjY=

Good Morning America article regarding ITMFM: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/amp/news/story/meet-sister-podcasters-shedding-light-black-true-crime-97827749

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

Jasmine Lynn, 19, had plans to go out one night during her Fall 2009 semester. Jasmine, who was a  sophomore at Spelman College, was especially looking forward to her friend's party at nearby Clark Atlanta University. It seemed like a typical night until a fight breaks out just outside of her friend's campus apartment. Now, detectives must rely on the accounts of witnesses to piece together what really happened on the early morning of September 3, 2009. Would their statements help make or break this case? 

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/jasmine-lynn


Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlighting our podcast:
https://www.instagram.com/p/Cp88TlNOD3F/?igshid=Mzc1MmZhNjY=

Good Morning America article regarding ITMFM: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/amp/news/story/meet-sister-podcasters-shedding-light-black-true-crime-97827749

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

 On June 24, 2018, Aniya Mack, 24, left her home for a meeting regarding an upcoming performance at her church—Second Baptist Church in Kalamazoo, Michigan. Her boyfriend, Donnovan Lewis, was adamant that this was Aniya's last known location. It had been days since he and Aniya's family heard from Aniya. Now, detectives are working quickly to piece together what really happened to her, as clues start to unravel a secret life. Could this be the missing piece to finding Aniya?   

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/aniya-mack


Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlighting our podcast:
https://www.instagram.com/p/Cp88TlNOD3F/?igshid=Mzc1MmZhNjY=

Good Morning America article regarding ITMFM: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/amp/news/story/meet-sister-podcasters-shedding-light-black-true-crime-97827749

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

On September 24, 1983, Sabrina Buie, 11, went to her friend’s house to drop off a bike.  Her sister, Tenita, who was 4 years old at the time, notes that it was the last time she saw Sabrina alive.  Detectives are eager to solve this case by any means necessary, but will this stance benefit Sabrina’s family or torpedo the case?

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/sabrina-buie


Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlighting our podcast:
https://www.instagram.com/p/Cp88TlNOD3F/?igshid=Mzc1MmZhNjY=

Good Morning America article regarding ITMFM: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/amp/news/story/meet-sister-podcasters-shedding-light-black-true-crime-97827749

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

Cherice Ragins, 24, planned to spend the weekend with her boyfriend Travis like she had many times before. But when her mother didn’t hear from Cherice on the night of February 19, 2010, and the days that followed, she became extremely worried. It was not like Cherice to not check in with her mother, Clariese. When she later learns that Cherice did in fact spend the weekend with Travis at his parent’s house, she feels somewhat relieved. But that relief was short lived when Travis could not account for Cherice’s whereabouts after walking together to the bus stop that Sunday evening. Cherice was supposed to take the bus back to Baltimore but she never arrived home. Will detectives be able to piece together what really happened to Cherice?

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/cherice-ragins


Attorney Benjamin Crump's Instagram post highlighting our podcast:
https://www.instagram.com/p/Cp88TlNOD3F/?igshid=Mzc1MmZhNjY=

Good Morning America article regarding ITMFM: https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/amp/news/story/meet-sister-podcasters-shedding-light-black-true-crime-97827749

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

In the summer of 2013, Danielle Locklear moved to North Carolina to live with her grandparents and her aunt, while her mom dealt with a painful divorce.   Danielle was excited to have a distraction from that -- and in came in the form of a new love interest: Je'Michael.  It wouldn’t take long for Danielle, 15, to get acclimated to North Carolina —she got straight A’s and made lots of friends. All was going well until one night in 2014 when Danielle left her house to return a book to her neighbor/ friend and never came back. Her disappearance was a huge shock to her family, friends and community -- and they immediately sprung into action along with law enforcement.  Will their concerted effort help to bring Danielle back home?

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/danielle-locklear

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

 Ayesha Turner was a young mother of two—a 5-year-old and 12-year-old. Ayesha had graduated Everest College as a medical assistant and was starting to get her life in order. But on the evening of October 5, 2012, Ayesha would leave the home she shared with her mother and kids and never return. Ayesha’s mother stated that this was out of character for her daughter and reported her missing immediately. The weeks that followed would bring forth a series of third-party statements sending detectives in a frenzy to find out what happened to Ayesha and why. Will they be able to crack the case before the Thanksgiving holiday? 

Disclaimer: This case contains violence and the dismembering of a body. As always, listeners’ discretion is advised.

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/ayesha-turner

Oxygen Article about Our Podcast: https://www.oxygen.com/true-crime-buzz/favorite-true-crime-podcasts-by-black-creators 

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

Michelle Blair had four children: Gabi, Stoni, Stephen and Matthew.  To the outside world, she appeared to be a devoted mother and her children appeared to lead happy lives.   However, behind closed doors, the children were subjected to inhumane behavior — and what could make this situation more disturbing? It was all at the hands of someone who they thought would protect them.

Disclaimer: This case contains violence against children.  As always, listeners’ discretion is advised.

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/blair-berry

Oxygen Article about Our Podcast: https://www.oxygen.com/true-crime-buzz/favorite-true-crime-podcasts-by-black-creators 

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

In 2014, Felecia Williams was just a 9-year-old in the third grade. Like most children her age, Felecia was inquisitive yet naive. The second youngest of six girls, Felecia developed a close relationship with her neighbor and family friend, Eboni Wiley. But this close bond would be forever broken by the events that transpired on May 16, 2014. Felecia was missing and Eboni could not account for the child's whereabouts, leaving Felecia's family and investigators baffled. So, did Eboni possibly have something to do with Felecia's disappearance?  

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/felecia-williams

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links

 In Part 1, we leave off with the "conclusion" of Marshall Jr.'s case.  However, at that point in time (1996), Michelle Soto's case was still unsolved.  In Part 2, we continue to unravel this story, introduce Deborah and try to make sense of the "pattern" between the murders. 

For a list of sources from today's episode and pictures, please visit www.itsthemysteryforme.com/episodes/michellesoto

Our Social Media: www.itsthemysteryforme.com/links