Brett McCollum ran his own investment operation for a decade, did hundreds of deals, and thought he'd made it, until back-to-back contractor issues and a market shift wiped out over $1 million in a little over a year and took his business nearly to zero. In this raw and honest episode, he shares what actually pulled him out, and it's not what most people would guess.
Now leading REI growth at PropertyRadar and hosting the On the Clock podcast, Brett opens up about reacting instead of responding, abandoning his Profit First discipline to juggle buckets, and the marriage conversation that became the real turning point. He and David also dig into why most investors waste time with AI, and how PropertyRadar's distress scoring and court-sourced data help you reach real sellers first. If you've ever hit rock bottom or wondered if you should quit, this one is for you.
Timeline Summary
[2:20] – The biggest shift Brett has seen from getting a behind-the-scenes look at top investors
[3:10] – His contrarian take that most people don't know how to use AI to produce real revenue
[4:00] – Why AI gives you a dopamine hit and sends you down time-wasting rabbit holes
[4:58] – The both/and: using AI to complement human performance, not as a crutch
[6:38] – Why you should only take AI advice from someone who can prove it on a P&L
[7:23] – Getting back to fundamentals first, then layering AI in
[8:12] – The setup: buying 22 houses in under three months at the top of the 2022 market
[9:34] – Contractor fallout and market signals he missed, costing multiple six figures
[10:36] – Trying to fix it alone instead of asking for help, and reacting emotionally
[11:00] – Breaking Profit First protocol by paying from different buckets to cover losses
[11:42] – Losing over $1 million in a year and going nearly to zero, back to back to back
[12:06] – The toll it took on him as a husband and father
[13:17] – His father's pattern of quitting and the childhood poverty and homelessness behind it
[13:57] – Setting pride aside, making phone calls, and finding great organizations to work with
[14:19] – Tom Krol's line that rock bottom is a very firm foundation
[15:41] – The "finish" tattoo and the decision to never be the guy who quits
[16:02] – His wife's turning-point words: if we're right, we'll figure out everything else
[18:10] – David on why seeing a counselor monthly is the engine behind his own ability to travel and work
[20:56] – No man is an island, and the distinction that no one does the work for you but people are there for you
[23:34] – Why Profit First is really the put-first-things-first principle applied to your whole life
[23:53] – Brené Brown's The Gifts of Imperfection on courage, compassion, and connection
[24:50] – What PropertyRadar is and its simple approach to seller data
[26:00] – The distress score built on real signals, not arbitrary list stacking
[27:03] – The dynamic, AI-driven lists that refresh every 15 minutes and auto-run outreach
[28:03] – The court-sourced divorce and probate data that arrives before it's ever recorded
[31:14] – Brett's Profit First advice: delayed gratification and discipline over reacting
5 Key Takeaways
- Most Investors Waste Time With AI — After seeing behind the scenes at hundreds of top operations, Brett's take is that AI has become a shiny object. Only take AI advice from someone who can prove it made them money on a P&L, and get your fundamentals right first.
- Reacting Instead Of Responding Kills You — When deals went sideways, Brett reacted emotionally, abandoned Profit First, and started juggling buckets to cover losses. That lack of discipline is what turned one bad deal into a million-dollar hole.
- Rock Bottom Is A Firm Foundation — Brett went nearly to zero but refused to quit, set his pride aside, and made the calls he'd avoided. Had he reached out a year earlier, he'd have saved himself a year of panic attacks and heartache.
- Your Marriage Is The Real Engine — The actual turning point was his wife telling him that if the two of them were right, everything else would follow. Investors who bring their spouse along and protect that relationship have the foundation to get through anything.
- Profit First Is A Tool You Have To Use — The model only works if you keep the discipline when the rubber meets the road. Follow it and a sideways deal won't hurt as badly. Abandon it under stress and you end up at zero.
Links & Resources
- PropertyRadar (5-day free trial) — https://www.propertyradar.com
- On the Clock podcast (hosted by Brett McCollum) — https://www.propertyradar.com/on-the-clock
- Simple CFO — https://simplecfo.com
- Profit First for Real Estate Investing by David Richter — https://profitfirstrei.com
- The Gifts of Imperfection by Brené Brown — https://brenebrown.com
- The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People by Stephen Covey — https://www.franklincovey.com
Enjoyed This Episode?
If Brett's honesty about losing everything and clawing back gave you the nerve to pick up the phone and call the person you've been avoiding, then do it before you do anything else. Share this episode with an investor who's hiding in a hole through a hard season, and follow the show and leave a rating and review so more real estate investors can hear that rock bottom really can be a firm foundation.