What happens when a movement built on moral seriousness gives way to one powered by cruelty, resentment, and nihilism?

In this episode, New York Times columnist David Brooks joins to talk about what he calls one of the greatest ruptures of his lifetime: the implosion of the conservative movement’s moral center.

Drawing from his widely discussed essay in The Atlantic “I Should Have Seen This Coming,” Brooks offers a deeply personal—and deeply unsettling—account of how a reactionary fringe rose to power and reshaped American public life. Together, Moore and Brooks trace the descent from Burkean virtue to clickbait outrage, from civic institutions to “own-the-libs” performance art.

But this conversation doesn’t stop at diagnosis. The two turn toward questions of cultural repair and spiritual renewal: Is there any real possibility of revival—in literature, in politics, in faith? What might it look like to recover a moral vision strong enough to resist the acid of our age?

And what role could Christians play in offering a better way?

Along the way, they talk about why the next spiritual awakening might not look like the last one, the legacy of Tim Keller, how we can engage in conversations on issues of the soul, how the Trump White House culture is different from other presidents’ and whether AI is really going to change American life as much as Moore thinks it will.

This is a candid, searching conversation about what it means to be human in a disordered world—and what kind of moral courage is needed to hold fast when the center does not.

Resources mentioned in this episode or recommended by the guest include:

David’s Atlantic article, I Should Have Seen This Coming

Buckley: The Life and the Revolution That Changed America by Sam Tanenhaus

David’s article that talks about Alasdair MacIntyre in The Atlantic, Why Do So Many People Think Trump is Good?

Diminish Democracy by Julian J. Rothbaum

The Revolt of the Elites and the Betrayal of Democracy by Christopher Lasch 

David’s New York Times Article: When Novels Mattered 

David’s novel suggestions:

Crossing to Safety by Wallace Stegner

War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy

Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy 

Selected Essays by Samuel Johnson 

Middlemarch by George Eliot

Keep up with Russell:

Sign up for the weekly newsletter where Russell shares thoughtful takes on big questions, offers a Christian perspective on life, and recommends books and music he's enjoying.

Submit a question for the show at [email protected] 

Subscribe to the Christianity Today Magazine: Special offer for listeners of The Russell Moore Show: Click here for 25% off a subscription

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices