In this solo episode of the play on words from Big City Readers we’re diving into some hot topics that spark debates in classrooms, on playgrounds, and at the family dinner table. From controversial children’s books like The Giving Tree and I’ll Love You Forever to the polarizing tradition of the Elf on the Shelf, we’ll explore why these stories and traditions can feel tricky for parents and educators. We’ll also share practical tips for teaching kids about boundaries—both in their relationships and in the stories we share with them. Whether you’re a fan, a skeptic, or just looking for alternatives, there’s something for everyone in this discussion.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode:

1. The Controversy Around Classic Books:Why some parents and educators hesitate to read The Giving Tree and I’ll Love You Forever.
   Themes of self-sacrifice, overbearing love, and their modern-day interpretations.
   How to approach these books thoughtfully or find alternative stories.
   
2. Elf on the Shelf: Fun or Frustration? The pressure parents feel to participate in this growing tradition.
   Why the Elf is so polarizing—modeling mischief, behavior tracking, and adding to holiday stress.
   Should the Elf be in classrooms?
   Tips for balancing holiday magic without burnout.
   
3. How to Teach Good Boundaries:Why boundaries matter for kids—and how to model them in everyday life.
   Using books and traditions to open conversations about consent, respect, and reciprocity.
   Alternatives to “behavior management” tools like the Elf and what they teach kids.
   

Why You’ll Love This Episode:
Whether you’re deciding how to handle a beloved (or dreaded) tradition or reflecting on the stories shaping your child’s world, this episode offers a compassionate, judgment-free look at how to navigate it all. You’ll leave with practical ideas for making choices that work for your family while helping your kids build strong, healthy boundaries.

Join the Conversation:
We want to hear from you! What’s your take on The Giving Tree, I’ll Love You Forever, or Elf on the Shelf? Share your thoughts and creative alternatives with us on Instagram @BigCityReaders or send us a message!

Get my favorite books here: amazon.com/shop/bigcityreaders

Rate & Subscribe:
If you loved this episode, don’t forget to subscribe and leave a review. Your feedback helps us create content that inspires and supports you!