That's Church.

S2 E48: Sisterhood, Nuance, & Speaking up with Allyson Reynolds & Tiffany Sowby


Listen Later

Rising Violet

Before we dive in, we want to highlight Rising Violet, the nonprofit Tiffany founded. Rising Violet provides one-time $1,000 gifts to women pursuing financial independence, with priority given to mothers who once relied on a partner and now need to be self-supporting. Applications are accepted three times a year (deadlines: Jan 31, May 31, Sep 30). Applicants must live in the U.S., complete a short essay and call with a board member, and consent to a background check limited to financial crimes. These gifts are a powerful way to help women move toward stability with dignity.


Episode summary

Allyson Reynolds and Tiffany Sowby, co-hosts of The Sisterhood Podcast, join us to talk about friendship, faith, and the power of hard conversations. Their podcast was born out of a love for women’s stories and a need for candid dialogue around the intersection of faith, politics, social issues, and interfaith experiences. Together, they’ve built a space where women who love the gospel but sometimes struggle with the church can feel less alone.


About our guests

The Sisterhood Podcast grew from Allyson and Tiffany’s years of writing and organizing with Power of Moms. Over time it has evolved into an encouraging place for women across the faith spectrum—orthodox, nuanced, or post-LDS.

Allyson grew up mostly in the Midwest, has lived all over the U.S., and now lives in Minnesota.

Tiffany was born and raised in England and now lives in Utah. Together they’re raising nine kids, plus a dog and some goats.


What we cover

• The friendship and creative spark that led to The Sisterhood Podcast

• Why they resisted becoming “just another Mormon mom podcast” and leaned into broader women’s issues

• How interfaith experiences shaped their faith and outlook

• Backing each other up in church conversations, not just speaking out

• Creating a welcoming space across the faith spectrum

• Why practice makes hard conversations easier


Stories & themes

Tiffany’s interfaith childhood: growing up LDS near London alongside Catholic, Muslim, and Hindu friends

Allyson’s perspective shift: from an “only true church” mindset in the Midwest to learning from a Muslim roommate at BYU and later a mission in Japan

Utah culture chats: the “mission field” mindset and assumptions about who is or isn’t LDS

Learning to speak up: why courage and community matter in making space for diverse voices


Books mentioned

If the Tide Turns — Rachel Rueckert

The Distance Between Us — Reyna Grande

The Courage to Be Disliked — Ichiro Kishimi & Fumitake Koga


Light-hearted closers

Stories of bumpers needing babysitters, surprise window encounters after a shower, and awkward pediatrician moments because we always end with humor.


Connect with us

Follow along for updates on episodes, events, field trips, and our upcoming retreat:

• Instagram: @thatschurchpodcast

• Website: thatschurch.org

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

That's Church.By Emilie Call and Ashlie Sanders

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

24 ratings


More shows like That's Church.

View all
Better Than Happy by Jody Moore

Better Than Happy

5,680 Listeners

Leading Saints Podcast by Leading Saints

Leading Saints Podcast

1,227 Listeners

One Heart One Mind by Thomas McConkie

One Heart One Mind

660 Listeners

Mormon Land by The Salt Lake Tribune

Mormon Land

332 Listeners

Faith Matters by Faith Matters Foundation

Faith Matters

1,761 Listeners

Listen, Learn & Love Hosted by Richard Ostler by Richard Ostler

Listen, Learn & Love Hosted by Richard Ostler

854 Listeners

All In by LDS Living

All In

6,505 Listeners

Conversations with Dr. Jennifer by Dr. Jennifer Finlayson-Fife

Conversations with Dr. Jennifer

44 Listeners

All Out in the Open by All Out in the Open, Questions from the Closet

All Out in the Open

1,198 Listeners

At Last She Said It by Cynthia Winward, Susan Hinckley

At Last She Said It

1,048 Listeners

Unshaken Saints by Jared Halverson

Unshaken Saints

2,627 Listeners

Breaking Down Patriarchy by Amy McPhie Allebest

Breaking Down Patriarchy

609 Listeners

Magnify by LDS Living

Magnify

455 Listeners

Latter Day Struggles by Valerie Hamaker

Latter Day Struggles

840 Listeners

Church History Matters by Scripture Central

Church History Matters

2,109 Listeners