Afford Anything

Should I Choose a Roth vs. Traditional IRA and 401k for Early Retirement?


Listen Later

#128: Antonia, 27, wants to retire in 15 years. She's trying to figure out whether to contribute to pre-tax or after-tax retirement accounts.

Most financial advice for 20-somethings that she's encountered says to contribute to after-tax (Roth) retirement accounts. These articles assume that a 27-year-old will continue earning money for the next 30+ years, presumably escalating into higher tax brackets along the way.

By paying taxes upfront, these articles say, you'll enjoy 30+ years of compounding gains, which you'll be able to withdraw tax-exempt.

But what if, like Antonia, you're only 15 years from retirement? Should you stick with Roth tax treatment? Or is there wisdom in making retirement contributions with pre-tax money?

_____

Marisa is young, high-income, and highly risk-tolerant. She'd like to know: what asset allocation would I suggest for a young, risk-tolerant person? And is rebalancing her portfolio necessary, or just a distraction?

_____

Dylan owns his home outright. When he sells it, he'll collect about $100,000 after fees. He also has an additional $100,000 saved in cash.

He'd like to buy a home free-and-clear. What's the best way to approach this? Should he take out a home equity line of credit? A bridge loan? Something else?

_____

Pal lives in the San Francisco Bay Area. He recently bought his first rental property, and he's interested in building passive income and reach financial independence.

He's curious about credit card piggybacking, a side hustle by which a person with a high credit score adds another person with a low credit score as an authorized user to their card.

It seems like a legitimate way to earn extra money. Why aren't more people talking about this? Is there a problem he's overlooking?

_____

Anonymous, 24, says she knows next-to-nothing about investing. She has $6,500 in her Roth IRA, invested in a Washington Mutual Class A mutual fund, which is an actively-managed mutual fund with a front load.

Should she keep her money there? Or should she move it?

Her second question is about her 401k. She contributes 5 percent of her paycheck into a Roth 401k account, from which she invests in a Target Date retirement fund. Her employer doesn't match any contributions.

Her total contributions to both accounts (her Roth 401k and Roth IRA) equal $5,500 per year.

Should she stop contributing to her Roth 401k, so that she can focus her contributions on her Roth IRA?

____

Jeff and his wife are both 64. When he reads about retirement, the information is ambiguous about Social Security.

Let's say that he has $1 million saved towards retirement, which generates $40,000 annually at the 4 percent rule of thumb. Let's also say that he is eligible for Social Security income of $40,000 per year. Doesn't this mean he could retire on $80,000 per year? If so, then why do "4 percent rule" projections only talk about the portfolio portion?

____

Former financial advisor Joe Saul-Sehy and I discuss these questions on today's episode. Enjoy!

 

For links to resources mentioned in this episode, go to http://affordanything.com/episode128

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Afford AnythingBy Paula Pant | Cumulus Podcast Network

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

3,455 ratings


More shows like Afford Anything

View all
Mark Levin Podcast by Cumulus Podcast Network

Mark Levin Podcast

23,433 Listeners

Red Eye Radio by Cumulus Podcast Network

Red Eye Radio

1,266 Listeners

Money Guy Show by Brian Preston and Bo Hanson

Money Guy Show

3,222 Listeners

The Stacking Benjamins Show by StackingBenjamins.com | Cumulus Podcast Network

The Stacking Benjamins Show

1,992 Listeners

So Money with Farnoosh Torabi by Farnoosh Torabi

So Money with Farnoosh Torabi

1,953 Listeners

The BOB & TOM Show Free Podcast by The BOB & TOM Show | Cumulus Podcast Network

The BOB & TOM Show Free Podcast

1,154 Listeners

Your Money, Your Wealth by Joe Anderson, CFP® & Alan Clopine, CPA of Pure Financial Advisors

Your Money, Your Wealth

809 Listeners

Jim Rome's Daily Jungle by Cumulus Podcast Network

Jim Rome's Daily Jungle

992 Listeners

The Chris Plante Show by WMAL | Cumulus Podcast Network | Cumulus Media Washington

The Chris Plante Show

1,791 Listeners

Marriage Kids and Money: Personal Finance for Families by Andy Hill

Marriage Kids and Money: Personal Finance for Families

599 Listeners

ChooseFI by ChooseFI

ChooseFI

5,147 Listeners

Inside of You with Michael Rosenbaum by Cumulus Podcast Network

Inside of You with Michael Rosenbaum

10,157 Listeners

The Jim Rome Podcast by Cumulus Podcast Network

The Jim Rome Podcast

2,974 Listeners

Millionaires Unveiled by Jace Mattinson, CPA

Millionaires Unveiled

899 Listeners

BiggerPockets Money Podcast by BiggerPockets

BiggerPockets Money Podcast

3,080 Listeners

Mike Drop by Mike Ritland

Mike Drop

6,438 Listeners

The Jim Rome Show by Cumulus Podcast Network

The Jim Rome Show

728 Listeners

Earn & Invest by Jordan Grumet (Doc G)

Earn & Invest

439 Listeners

The Shawn Ryan Show by Shawn Ryan

The Shawn Ryan Show

44,325 Listeners

Risk Parity Radio by Frank Vasquez

Risk Parity Radio

268 Listeners

Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors - The Best Interest by Jesse Cramer

Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors - The Best Interest

136 Listeners

All the Hacks: Money, Points & Life by Chris Hutchins

All the Hacks: Money, Points & Life

1,613 Listeners

Two Sides of FI by Jason and Eric

Two Sides of FI

439 Listeners

Mile High FI Podcast by Doug Cunnington & Carl Jensen

Mile High FI Podcast

203 Listeners

The Benny Show by Benny Johnson

The Benny Show

2,283 Listeners

Talk Ville by Tom Welling & Michael Rosenbaum

Talk Ville

2,933 Listeners

Rich Valdés America At Night by Cumulus Podcast Network

Rich Valdés America At Night

85 Listeners

Catching Up to FI by Bill Yount & Jackie Cummings Koski

Catching Up to FI

345 Listeners

America In The Morning by Cumulus Podcast Network

America In The Morning

12 Listeners

U.S. Soccer Podcast by US Soccer | Cumulus Podcast Network

U.S. Soccer Podcast

42 Listeners

The Musers The Podcast by Cumulus Podcast Network

The Musers The Podcast

759 Listeners

Topical Fruit by Topical Fruit | Cumulus Podcast Network

Topical Fruit

3 Listeners

Next Role with Vernon Davis by Vernon Davis

Next Role with Vernon Davis

2 Listeners

Family Matters by CJ Pearson

Family Matters

7 Listeners