Tim and Joel’s cinematic showdown has reached its climax! Tim backed Moana 2 to crush it at the box office, while Joel, a self-proclaimed Wicked superfan, was certain he’d emerge victorious. The stakes? The loser has to dress up like the winning movie—coconut bra and wig for Joel or full green Elphaba paint for Tim.

The results are in, and it’s time to find out who’s suiting up (or painting up) for their public humiliation. Tune in for the hilarious reveal and to hear their reactions—this one’s a must-listen!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.