Analysis

Analysis

By BBC Radio 4NewsPolitics
Download on the App Store

Analysis episodes

  • Can the UK afford a mental health crisis?

    A record 2.6 million people are off work due to long-term sickness, with mental health conditions the biggest single contributor. The problem is particularly acute among younger people, who are disproportionately likely to cite poor mental health as their reason for not working. Other surveys suggest that poor mental health and burnout are among the top reasons for young people to quit their job. But should young people develop more resilience and “soldier on”, as older generations may have done, or is being more open about mental health a good thing? And how well are employers adapting to the expectations of younger workers when it comes to mental health and wellbeing?

    Contributors:
    Tim Gibbs, Head of Public Service Analysis Team, Office for National Statistics
    Emma Codd, Global Chief Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Officer, Deloitte
    Gabrielle Judge, Influencer and CEO, Anti Work Girlboss
    Joel Gujral, CEO and Founder, MYNDUP
    Dr Lucy Foulkes, Research Fellow in the Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Oxford
    Mel Stride, Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
    Alison McGovern, Shadow Minister for Work and Pensions
    With thanks to City, University of London

    Presenter: James Kirkup

    Producer: Dan Hardoon
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    29 min
  • France: a constitutional crisis in the making

    The USA, the UK and France, which have led the democratic world, are all suffering problems with their constitutions. But the problem is most acute in France, where President Macron has lost his parliamentary majority, and forced his pension reforms through by decree. But worse is to come; Macron can only serve as President until 2027 and will leave a vacuum at the heart of French politics when he steps down. And unlike Charles de Gaulle, he doesn’t seem likely to leave an enduring movement or an obvious successor. He hoovered up centrist support when he swept to power, and his main rivals now are either far-left or far-right. They both are populists, anti-NATO and pro-Putin. Edward Stourton explores if France is heading towards a constitutional crisis and asks what political turmoil in our nearest neighbour might mean.

    Presenter: Edward Stourton

    Producer: Jonathan IAnson
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    30 min
  • What on earth is the national interest?

    Should we be sceptical when politicians claim to act in "the national interest"? The phrase is frequently trotted out to elevate policy and actions as unimpeachably serving us all. But what does it actually mean? So far the Oxford English Dictionary has steered clear of pinning down this "slippery" term.

    Mark Damazer digs up its historical roots and talks to politicians, prime-ministerial speechwriters and policymakers to define a term that can obscure as much as it elucidates. Is its use just cynical high grounding or does it speak of a sincere effort to disentangle policy from personal or party interests? Is the national interest best served by a strong civic landscape where differing visions of “the national interest” are free to battle it out?

    Presenter: Mark Damazer

    Producer: David Reid
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    Contributors:

    Michael Gove, Minister for Levelling up, Housing and Communities
    Angela Rayner, shadow deputy prime minister and shadow levelling up secretary
    Phil Collins, former prime-ministerial speechwriter
    Munira Mirza, former Director of the No10 Policy Unit
    Dame Linda Colley, Professor of History at Princeton
    Fiona McPherson, Senior Editor at the Oxford English Dictionary, specialising in new words

    29 min
  • What makes a good school?

    How should we evaluate schools? Is it about delivering a wide range of subjects, or extra activities and pastoral care that make a “good” school? Who gets to decide what is a good school and what does that mean to different people? Many people are influenced by the four Ofsted grades and Ofsted reports so what does research tell us about how consistent those judgements are? Would you choose a school with a good local reputation but a lower inspection grade. The programme talks to Sonia Exley, an associate professor at the London School of Economics, Professor Christian Bokhove at the University of Southampton, Natalie Perera, chief executive of the Education Policy Institute, Andreas Schleicher, Director of Education and Skills at the OECD, George Leckie, Professor of Social Statistics at the University of Bristol,Dr Ellen Gleaves, a postdoctoral researcher.

    Presenter: Branwen Jeffreys

    Producer: Bob Howard
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    30 min
  • How can we grow the UK economy?

    The cost of living crisis followed a decade in which people’s wages and incomes barely grew. The idea that each generation does at least as well as the one before, has for the moment ended. We’ll only start getting better off again if we can get the economy growing – as it used to in the decades preceding the financial crisis. So, what levers can governments pull to get growth back into the system? Why don't governments do the things that nearly every expert thinks might work? Should we be looking to governments at all? Paul Johnson of the Institute for Fiscal Studies explores the challenges facing the UK economy and asks: how can any government get the UK economy growing?

    Presenter: Paul Johnson
    Producer: Farhana Haider
    Editor: Claire Fordham

    Contributors:
    Diane Coyle, Bennett Professor of Public Policy at the University of Cambridge.
    Jagjit Chadha, Director of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research
    Stephen Evans, Chief Executive of the Learning and Work Institute
    Richard Davies, Director of the Economics Observatory
    Louise Hellem, Chief economist at the CBI.
    Nicholas Macpherson, former Permanent Secretary at the Treasury.
    Rowan Crozier, CEO C. Brandauer & Co Ltd
    Sam Bowan, Editor of Works in Progress

    29 min
  • The Democratic Brain

    Our brain is a wonderful machine, but it can also short-circuit. What happens to us when emotions and politics intersect, when the democratic, listening brain is cut off, or when we succumb to ‘hate speech’? Research using the latest brain scanners shows that the older part of the brain called the amygdala is ‘triggered’ by emotional responses out of proportion to the impacting stimulus. So, perhaps are we after wolves in human clothing? Not necessarily; we have also developed the frontal cortex which the scans show is stimulated by rational argument. What can scanning the brain reveal about our political affiliations? Can the field of neuro-politics improve political discourse or leave us open to manipulation?

    Presenter: Matt Qvortrup

    Producer: Bob Howard
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    Contributors:

    Barbara Sahakian, Professor of Clinical Neuropsychology at the University of Cambridge
    Dr Darren Schreiber, Senior Lecturer at Exeter University
    Skyler Cranmer, Associate Professor at Ohio State University
    Dahlia Scheindlin, political consultant and public opinion researcher
    Dr Liya Yu, Columbia University

    29 min
  • How far should reparative justice go?

    Amid mounting claims for reparations for slavery and colonialism, historian Zoe Strimpel asks how far reparative justice should go.

    Should we limit reparations to the living survivors of state atrocities, such as the Holocaust, or should we re-write the rulebook to include the ancestors of victims who suffered historical injustices centuries ago?
    Alongside testimony from a Holocaust survivor and interviews with lawyers, historians and reparations advocates, Zoe hears about the long shadow cast by slavery - lumbering Caribbean states and societies with a legacy that they are still struggling with today.
    Are demands for slavery reparations just another front in the culture war designed to leverage white guilt? Will they inevitably validate countless other claims to rectify historical grievances? Or are they a necessary step for diverse societies to draw in the extremes of a polarised debate so we can write a common history that we can all live with?

    Presenter: Zoe Strimpel

    Producer: David Reid
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    Contributors

    Mala Tribich, Holocaust survivor.
    Michael Newman, Chief Executive, Association of Jewish Refugees.
    Albrecht Ritschtl, Professor of Economic History, London School of Economics
    Dr. Opal Palmer Adisa, former director, University of West Indies.
    Kenneth Feinberg, Master of the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund.
    Tomiwa Owolade, journalist and author of "This is not America".
    Alex Renton, journalist, author and co-founder of Heirs of Slavery.
    Dr Hardeep Dhillon, historian, University of Pennsylvania.
    James Koranyi, Associate Professor of modern European History at the University of Durham.

    30 min
  • Is there a new elite?

    People have always fought back against “The elite”, and until recently they were easily recognisable: rich, privileged and often born into money. Old Etonians, billionaires, oil barons, media tycoons ruled the roost, but there are claims things are changing, and the rise of a new elite is challenging the status quo.

    Author Matthew Goodwin calls them a group of “radical woke middle-class liberals completely out of step with the public”. University graduates working in creative industries, media and universities, who have an heavy influence over the national conversation about things like immigration, trans rights and sex education, but critics say they don’t represent “ordinary folk”, and as a result communities are feeling unrepresented and left behind.
    So who is in charge, or is there an unlikely, and unknowing, coalition between the two – the new elite dominating social discourse and cultural discussion, whilst the traditional elite pull the strings of politics and economics?
    This is the next chapter of the culture wars – but while the pair of them battle it out for supremacy, much of the country struggles on day-to-day watching from the side lines.

    Presenter: Neil Maggs

    Producer: Jonathan IAnson
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    Contributors

    Matt Goodwin, Professor of Politics, University of Kent and author "Values, Voice and Virtue".
    George Monbiot, Author, journalist and environmental campaigner
    Dr Lisa McKenzie, research fellow, University of Durham, writer and anarchist
    Bob & Lee, builders
    Dr Rakib Ehsan, Social policy analyst and author "Beyond Grievance"
    Baroness Tina Stowell of Beeston
    Paul Embery, Firefighter, trade unionist and writer
    Tom, boxing club owner
    Aaron Bastani, Broadcaster and founder of Novara Media

    29 min
  • Why are so many workers on strike?

    Will 2023 be known as the summer of discontent? This year, nearly every corner of the country has been affected by some kind of industrial action, and more is coming. Teachers, doctors, nurses, railway workers, airport security, civil servants are among the many professions which have called strikes to protest against, amongst other things, future pay packets during a cost of living crisis. But do labour union tactics really deliver for their members, or does the strong bargaining position of the government come out on top in the end?

    In this edition of Analysis, Faisal Islam hears from three top union leaders, along with industrial relations experts, about the challenges of calling and maintaining strike actions and the tolls it can take on members and the public. Where lies the balance of power between a workforce banding together to demand a better deal and the public which has to work around disappearing services?

    You can learn more about this topic by watching the BBC 2 documentary Strike: Inside the Unions available on BBC iPlayer.

    Contributors:

    Sharon Graham - General Secretary: Unite Union
    Mick Lynch - General Secretary: Rail, Maritime and Transport Union
    Pat Cullen - General Secretary: Royal College of Nursing
    Jerry Cope - Former Pay Review Body Chair
    Mark Stuart - Montague Burton Professor of Employment Relations, University of Leeds
    Lord Richard Balfe - Member, House of Lords

    Presenter: Faisal Islam

    Producer: Sandra Kanthal
    Editor: Clare Fordham
    Programme Coordinator: Maria Ogundele

    29 min
  • Does work have to be miserable?

    How can employers in all sectors of the UK economy get the best out of their workers, retain experienced staff, improve productivity and increase profits at the same time?

    The principles of "Job Design" seem to promise all of these benefits. It's a process of work innovation which focuses on people, their skills, their knowledge and how they interact with each other and technology, in every workplace, in every sector of the economy.

    Proponents claim it gives workers a voice in their workplace, allows them to balance their work and home lives, stops burnout and could get more of the economically inactive back in employment. But what evidence is there that it works - and how difficult would it be to implement changes in the workplace?

    Presenter: Pauline Mason

    Producer: Ravi Naik
    Editor: Clare Fordham

    Contributors:

    Patricia Findlay, Professor of Work and Employment Relations, University of Strathclyde and Director of the Scottish Centre for Employment Research.
    Kate Bennett, Labour ward coordinator at Liverpool Women's Hospital.
    Damian Grimshaw, Professor of Employment Studies, King's College London, and former head of research at the International Labour Organisation.
    Dame Diane Coyle, Bennett Professor, University of Cambridge and a director of the Productivity Institute.
    Rachel London, Deputy Chief People Officer at Liverpool Women's Hospital.
    Jenna Brimble. Midwife in the continuity of care team at Liverpool Women's Hospital.
    Heejung Chung, Professor of Sociology and Social Policy, University of Kent.
    Emma Stewart, Flexible working consultant and co-founder, Timewise.
    Dr Charlotte Gascoine independent researcher and consultant on flexible and part-time working
    Paul Dennett, Mayor of the City of Salford
    Jim Liptrot, Managing director, Howorth Air Tech.
    Stacey Bridge, Financial accounting assistant, Howorth Air Tech.

    29 min

About Analysis

From the publisher's feed

Programme examining the ideas and forces which shape public policy in Britain and abroad, presented by distinguished writers, journalists and academics.

More shows like Analysis

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,625 Listeners

From Our Own Correspondent by BBC Radio 4

From Our Own Correspondent

370 Listeners

More or Less by BBC Radio 4

More or Less

873 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,048 Listeners

The Reith Lectures by BBC Radio 4

The Reith Lectures

157 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,481 Listeners

The Documentary Podcast by BBC World Service

The Documentary Podcast

1,797 Listeners

In Our Time: History by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time: History

1,880 Listeners

6 Minute English by BBC Radio

6 Minute English

1,811 Listeners

Learning English Conversations by BBC Radio

Learning English Conversations

1,033 Listeners

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4 by BBC Radio 4

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4

2,116 Listeners

The Infinite Monkey Cage by BBC Radio 4

The Infinite Monkey Cage

1,907 Listeners

Profile by BBC Radio 4

Profile

106 Listeners

The Media Show by BBC Radio 4

The Media Show

34 Listeners

BBC Inside Science by BBC Radio 4

BBC Inside Science

395 Listeners

Moral Maze by BBC Radio 4

Moral Maze

69 Listeners

The Inquiry by BBC World Service

The Inquiry

726 Listeners

Start the Week by BBC Radio 4

Start the Week

161 Listeners

Any Questions? and Any Answers? by BBC Radio 4

Any Questions? and Any Answers?

42 Listeners

The Politics Show by The New Statesman

The Politics Show

124 Listeners

The Briefing Room by BBC Radio 4

The Briefing Room

59 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,225 Listeners

The Bomb by BBC World Service

The Bomb

1,004 Listeners

Westminster Insider by POLITICO

Westminster Insider

32 Listeners

Radical by BBC Radio 4

Radical

31 Listeners