Histoire intellectuelle de la Chine - Anne Cheng

Conférence - Takahiro Nakajima : Modern Japanese Sinology As an Imperial Discourse


Listen Later

Anne Cheng

Collège de France

Histoire intellectuelle de la Chine

Année 2024-2025

Conférence - Takahiro Nakajima : Modern Japanese Sinology As an Imperial Discourse

Takahiro Nakajima est invité par l'assemblée du Collège de France sur proposition de la professeure Anne Cheng.

Résumé

The Organization of Philosophy as an Institution

Inoue Tetsujirō claimed to have introduced the now widely used distinction between Western and Eastern philosophy in his Congratulatory Address to the 25th-anniversary celebration of Religious Studies at the Faculty of Letters of Tokyo Imperial University in 1930.

When the University of Tokyo was founded in 1877, it reorganized Tokyo Kaisei School and established a Faculty of Letters. The faculty was divided into two departments: the first department included history, philosophy, and political science, while the second department covered Japanese and Chinese literature. Chinese and Indian philosophy, categorized as Eastern philosophy, were initially placed within the second department. After multiple restructurings, by 1904, a three-department system of philosophy, history, and literature was established, which remained in place during the Tokyo Imperial University era. Eventually, philosophy was divided into Western philosophy and Eastern philosophy, with the latter further split into Chinese philosophy and Indian philosophy. Today we are focusing on Chinese philosophy.

Confucianism as Morality

Hattori Unokichi was a leading scholar of Chinese philosophy then. His primary concern was Confucianism, which he argued was not a religion but a system of morality. His perspective was shaped by contemporary developments in China, where Kang Youwei and others sought to establish Kongjiao (Confucian Religion), attempting to redefine Confucianism as a formal religion akin to Christianity. This movement, initiated during the Hundred Days' Reform of 1898 and briefly implemented in the early Republic of China (1910s), aimed to make Confucianism the spiritual foundation of modern China but ultimately failed to gain broad acceptance.

Hattori strongly opposed this movement, insisting that Confucianism should remain a moral philosophy devoid of religious elements. He criticized Kang Youwei and his followers for reinterpreting Confucius' statement "I have long prayed" to claim that he engaged in religious prayer. In contrast, Hattori argued that Confucius entirely rejected prayer. According to Hattori, Confucianism—or what he called Kōkyō—was not a religion but a secular ethical system.

The Philosophy of Empire

Hattori's Kōkyō was a moralized and ethicized version of Confucianism. By redefining Confucianism as philosophy or ethics rather than religion, he argued that it could achieve universal validity. To accomplish this, elements like prayer had to be eliminated. This process would make Confucianism universally acceptable and position Japan as its rightful successor and global advocate, replacing China. Hattori's emphasis on philosophy and ethics in Confucianism was driven by Japan's imperial ambitions, seeking to elevate itself as a leading intellectual and cultural power.

Takase Takejirō: Yōmei-ism and the Study of Mozi

Takase Takejirō, a modern Yangming (Yōmei) scholar, explored the relationship between Mozi and Christianity. He argued that Mozi's teachings closely resembled Christianity, particularly in their advocacy for universal love and opposition to war. During the interwar period between the First Sino-Japanese War and the Russo-Japanese War, Takase criticized Mozi for promoting ideas similar to Christian pacifism.

Criticism of Christianity as a religion had already been intensifying following the Uchimura Kanzō Disrespect Incident of 1891 and the publication of Inoue Tetsujirō's The Conflict Between Education and Religion (Keigyōsha, 1893). In response, Inoue promoted the concept of national morality, emphasizing the necessity of ethics to support the state. Modern Yōmei-ism became a key intellectual discourse supporting this ideology. Takase's critique of Mozi was developed within this broader historical and ideological context.

Takase Takejirō: Laozi-Zhuangzi Philosophy

Another major work by Takase was Laozi-Zhuangzi Philosophy (1909). At that time, European Oriental Studies were grappling with 19th-century scholarly concerns, particularly philology and comparative studies, in their efforts to interpret Eastern texts. A central debate in this field concerned the origins of Laozi: Were they derived from India, the Middle East, or uniquely Chinese?

Takase engaged with scholars such as Jean-Pierre Abel-Rémusat and Pierre Lafitte from France, Robert Douglas from Britain, and Paul Carus from the United States. His work reflected a struggle to position Laozi within global intellectual history.

European Orientalists sought to incorporate non-Western traditions into a comprehensible framework, often struggling to reconcile ancient texts with Christian theological concepts. In this context, Laozi presented a challenge due to its antiquity, predating Christian narratives. Takase's work was an attempt to engage with these global debates on the origins and significance of Chinese philosophy.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Histoire intellectuelle de la Chine - Anne ChengBy Collège de France

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

2 ratings


More shows like Histoire intellectuelle de la Chine - Anne Cheng

View all
L'esprit public by France Culture

L'esprit public

74 Listeners

Répliques by France Culture

Répliques

118 Listeners

L'Entretien archéologique by France Culture

L'Entretien archéologique

27 Listeners

Le Cours de l'histoire by France Culture

Le Cours de l'histoire

125 Listeners

Cultures monde by France Culture

Cultures monde

54 Listeners

Affaires étrangères by France Culture

Affaires étrangères

130 Listeners

Paléontologie humaine - Michel Brunet by Collège de France

Paléontologie humaine - Michel Brunet

0 Listeners

Philosophie du langage et de la connaissance - Jacques Bouveresse by Collège de France

Philosophie du langage et de la connaissance - Jacques Bouveresse

0 Listeners

Milieux Bibliques - Thomas Römer by Collège de France

Milieux Bibliques - Thomas Römer

5 Listeners

La Conversation scientifique by France Culture

La Conversation scientifique

67 Listeners

Les Nuits de France Culture by France Culture

Les Nuits de France Culture

39 Listeners

Histoire du Coran. Texte et transmission - François Déroche by Collège de France

Histoire du Coran. Texte et transmission - François Déroche

0 Listeners

Les Grandes Traversées by France Culture

Les Grandes Traversées

37 Listeners

Économie des institutions, de l'innovation et de la croissance - Philippe Aghion by Collège de France

Économie des institutions, de l'innovation et de la croissance - Philippe Aghion

1 Listeners

Culture écrite de l'antiquité tardive et papyrologie byzantine - Jean-Luc Fournet by Collège de France

Culture écrite de l'antiquité tardive et papyrologie byzantine - Jean-Luc Fournet

0 Listeners

La Science, CQFD by France Culture

La Science, CQFD

73 Listeners

Innovation technologique Liliane Bettencourt (2016-2017) - Didier Roux by Collège de France

Innovation technologique Liliane Bettencourt (2016-2017) - Didier Roux

0 Listeners

Chaire Européenne (2016-2017) - Alain Wijffels by Collège de France

Chaire Européenne (2016-2017) - Alain Wijffels

0 Listeners

Le Nouvel Esprit Public by Philippe Meyer

Le Nouvel Esprit Public

76 Listeners

Storiavoce, un podcast d'Histoire & Civilisations by Storiavoce

Storiavoce, un podcast d'Histoire & Civilisations

36 Listeners

Paroles d'histoire by Paroles d'histoire

Paroles d'histoire

16 Listeners

Le Collimateur by Alexandre Jubelin / Binge Audio

Le Collimateur

37 Listeners

Philosophie du langage et de l'esprit - François Recanati by Collège de France

Philosophie du langage et de l'esprit - François Recanati

0 Listeners

Informatique et sciences numériques (2013-2014) - Nicholas Ayache by Collège de France

Informatique et sciences numériques (2013-2014) - Nicholas Ayache

0 Listeners

Innovation technologique Liliane Bettencourt (2014-2015) - Bernard Meunier by Collège de France

Innovation technologique Liliane Bettencourt (2014-2015) - Bernard Meunier

0 Listeners

Librairie Mollat by librairie Mollat

Librairie Mollat

0 Listeners

Innovation technologique Liliane Bettencourt (2018-2019) - Molly Przeworski by Collège de France

Innovation technologique Liliane Bettencourt (2018-2019) - Molly Przeworski

0 Listeners

Mondes Francophones (2018-2019) - Yanick Lahens by Collège de France

Mondes Francophones (2018-2019) - Yanick Lahens

0 Listeners

L'invention de l'Europe par les langues et les cultures (2022-2023) - Mieke Bal by Collège de France

L'invention de l'Europe par les langues et les cultures (2022-2023) - Mieke Bal

0 Listeners

Pauvreté et politiques publiques - Esther Duflo by Collège de France

Pauvreté et politiques publiques - Esther Duflo

1 Listeners

Histoire des Lumières, XVIIIe-XXIe siècle - Antoine Lilti by Collège de France

Histoire des Lumières, XVIIIe-XXIe siècle - Antoine Lilti

3 Listeners

Chaire internationale (2007-2008) - Pierre Magistretti by Collège de France

Chaire internationale (2007-2008) - Pierre Magistretti

0 Listeners

Biodiversité et écosystèmes (2023-2024) - Emmanuelle Porcher by Collège de France

Biodiversité et écosystèmes (2023-2024) - Emmanuelle Porcher

0 Listeners

Formation planétaire : de la Terre aux exoplanète - Alessandro Morbidelli by Collège de France

Formation planétaire : de la Terre aux exoplanète - Alessandro Morbidelli

0 Listeners

Mondes francophones (2023-2024) - Salikoko S. Mufwene by Collège de France

Mondes francophones (2023-2024) - Salikoko S. Mufwene

0 Listeners