Earlier this year, I made what I can only describe as a "rookie" niching mistake. I built my new positioning around something my current clients talked to me about constantly, people responded really well to it, and some even reached out about working together. Then the conversations with new prospects kept ending with, "This sounds great. But I'm not ready yet."
That pattern forced me to look at the difference between what my current clients value after they've worked with me and what prospective clients already know they want before they hire me.
In this episode, I'm sharing how I missed that distinction, the data that finally made it impossible to ignore, and what I'm changing about my niche, messaging, and the backbone of The Foundry curriculum as a result.
The deeper work around building a business that fits your strengths, personality, capacity, and life still matters to me. I just realized it wasn't the right thing to lead with if I wanted new clients to understand why they should work with me now.
If people are responding to your content but your sales conversations keep stalling at "later," this episode will help you figure out whether you have a sales problem, a messaging problem, or a niche that's asking people to want something they're not ready to pay for yet.
And if you're an experienced coach or practitioner whose work already gets results, but your signature offer still takes too much explaining or selling, this conversation is especially relevant.
Timeline Highlights
[00:00] – The rookie niching mistake: choosing a topic before validating buyer demand
[03:47] – Why I decided to move upmarket and speak to more advanced entrepreneurs
[08:17] – The client conversations that shaped my messaging around strengths, burnout, and business fit
[15:02] – Where the strategy broke: people liked the outcome but didn't want it enough to buy
[16:38] – The sales data that exposed the mismatch between positive response and buying intent
[21:33] – Why current-client insight can miss what prospective clients already know they want
[24:32] – The role messaging and positioning must play when trust hasn't been earned through delivery
[29:26] – How I'm rebuilding my niche around value, skill, joy, and active demand
[34:35] – The experienced coaches and practitioners I'm choosing to serve now
[39:01] – Why personality and strengths remain part of my perspective without leading the offer
[45:44] – How to diagnose a market-demand mismatch instead of blaming the market
[47:51] – The offer, sales system, and marketing plan behind the next version of The Foundry
Top Quotes from the Episode
- "People saying 'this sounds great' isn't the same as people wanting it enough to pay for it."
- "I was speaking to what my clients valued after working with me, not what prospective clients already knew they wanted."
- "If 'I'm not ready' keeps coming up, you have to consider whether you're leading with a problem people want solved right now."
- "Your messaging has to earn the trust of people who haven't had the chance to experience your work yet."
- "A profitable niche comes down to what people will pay for, what you're exceptionally good at, and the work you actually want to do."
- "Being ahead of the curve is helpful until you're so far ahead that people admire your idea but aren't ready to buy it."
- "The mistake isn't the problem. Refusing to look honestly at why something isn't working is the problem."
Links & Resources
Join The Foundry waitlist
Take the What's Your CEO Type? Quiz