We Didn't Turn Out OK with Jennie Monness

19: From Dating Doubts to Mom Confidence with Lindsey Metselaar


Listen Later

In this episode, I sit down with OG podcast host Lindsey Metselaar of We Met at Acme a a show where singles turn for unfiltered dating advice. Lindsey started her podcast at 27 after being dumped on her birthday, and now she’s married, a mom, and still telling it like it is. What struck me most about Lindsey is how grounded and confident she is, even just 15 months into motherhood. She’s figuring it out in real time and learning more about herself along the way..

Key Takeaways:

  • The Butterfly Effect of Love: Lindsey and I reflect on the tiny moments that lead us to our partners - and even the babies that feel meant for us. (Spoiler: You might be surprised by how I met Matt!)

  • Imposter Syndrome: Lindsey shares how she once questioned herself as a host of a dating podcast before meeting “her person,” and how those doubts don’t continue to creep in as much at least - as a married mom she feels its the ultimate testament to how it all ends up working out.

  • Real Confidence: Lindsey credits her success to letting go of what others think.

  • Control & IVF: We both open up about our fertility journeys and how releasing control in that process prepared us for motherhood - teaching us how to trust.

  • Perfectionism & Type-A Tendencies: From IVF to birth plans, Lindsey shares how striving for control and perfection clashed with real life - and how letting go allowed space for so much more.

  • Parenting with Perspective: We discuss how reflecting on who we were as children helps guide the way we parent today.

  • Handling the Haters: I talk about how I process negativity by imagining how I’d want my daughters to respond to it. It’s not about me - it’s about modeling strength for them.

  • Mean Girl Moms: We touch on the subtle (and not-so-subtle) ways adult behavior impacts the kids we’re raising.

    This episode feels like a cozy hangout with two moms keeping it real. It’s open, honest, and filled with the kind of conversation you want over coffee - honestly, I’m ready to start a series with Lindsey.

    You can find Lindsey on Instagram at @wemetatacme and @wemetatbaby and listen to her on her own podcast We Met at Acme available wherever you listen to podcasts.


    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    We Didn't Turn Out OK with Jennie MonnessBy Jennie Monness

    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8

    4.8

    21 ratings


    More shows like We Didn't Turn Out OK with Jennie Monness

    View all
    The Skinny Confidential Him & Her Show by Lauryn Bosstick & Michael Bosstick / Dear Media

    The Skinny Confidential Him & Her Show

    14,912 Listeners

    We Met At Acme by Dear Media, Lindsey Metselaar

    We Met At Acme

    2,423 Listeners

    Second Life by Second Life

    Second Life

    2,861 Listeners

    the goop podcast by gwyneth paltrow

    the goop podcast

    6,730 Listeners

    Not Skinny But Not Fat by Dear Media, Amanda Hirsch

    Not Skinny But Not Fat

    6,120 Listeners

    Conversations with Cam by Dear Media

    Conversations with Cam

    1,571 Listeners

    Well with Arielle Lorre by Dear Media, Arielle Lorre

    Well with Arielle Lorre

    4,048 Listeners

    With Whit by Dear Media, Whitney Port

    With Whit

    1,322 Listeners

    Raising Good Humans by Dear Media, Aliza Pressman

    Raising Good Humans

    1,875 Listeners

    Lipstick on the Rim by Sony Music Entertainment

    Lipstick on the Rim

    996 Listeners

    The World's First Podcast with Erin & Sara Foster by Dear Media | Wishbone Production

    The World's First Podcast with Erin & Sara Foster

    2,716 Listeners

    It's Me, Tinx by Tinx

    It's Me, Tinx

    4,144 Listeners

    Move With Heart by with Melissa Wood-Tepperberg

    Move With Heart

    1,132 Listeners

    The Wellness Process by Dear Media

    The Wellness Process

    313 Listeners

    We Are More Than Moms by Peoples Media

    We Are More Than Moms

    63 Listeners