Episode Summary:
Amy Reid has cracked the reader-relationship code with her subscribers — and you better bet that I dug in when I got her on the Happy Subscribers podcast this week!
As a baking recipe blogger, Amy has locked in on what her readers want, engaged with them 1:1 through email replies, and prioritizes email marketing as her favorite way to connect with her audience. (Dawwww! ❤️)
In Fall of 2025, Amy didn't just launch a cookbook — she found out how truly engaged (and willing to spend their hard-earned money) her email community is. Her first pre-order email generated 300+ sales in 24 hours… all because she's been nurturing her list long before she asked for the sale (what she calls "the plea" 😂)
Amy proves that strong relationships + thoughtful email strategy = real results.
Not overnight. Not from a viral reel.
But from genuine connection, built over time.
Tune in to hear how she does it — and what you can borrow for your own email strategy.
In this episode, you'll learn about:
- How her readers helped her find the vision (and topic) for writing her first cookbook
- What's in her welcome sequence that connects with new subscribers so deeply, so fast
- How she organized, assigned recipes, and got feedback from the 300 recipe testers on her email list
- The heartbreak of doing a cold subscriber clean-up (and whether it's worth it)
- How Amy's using AI to support her writing — while also keeping email personal by sharing anecdotes with her recipes
Check out this episode's blog post Connect with Amy:Instagram Scottish Bakes Cookbook Join Amy's Newsletter Episode Resources: Duett Free Resources Join the Duett Newsletter
Duett Services:
Email Strategy Playbook - A fresh set of eyes and insight into your current email marketing
The Duett Debut - Done for you email copywrting & automation setup
Ready, Set, EMAIL - Quick & custom email setup to grow and send your newsletter fast
Book a FREE Discovery Call
Instagram @alleagrummert